Prosecutor demands confession of 20 lies for Menendez brothers’ freedom bid

Lyle and Erik Menendez, sentenced to life in prison for the 1989 murder of their parents Jose and Kitty Menendez, face a new hurdle in their decades-long fight for freedom. On March 10, 2025, Los Angeles District Attorney Nathan Hochman announced he is withdrawing a resentencing motion filed by his predecessor, George Gascón, in October 2024. Hochman conditioned any potential support for a sentence reduction on the brothers fully admitting to 20 alleged lies they’ve told over 35 years to cover up the crime, claiming they’ve only acknowledged 4 so far. The decision reverses a prior push to reduce their life sentences to 50 years, which would have made them immediately eligible for parole due to time served. It comes as the Menendez brothers, now 57 and 54, prepare for a critical resentencing hearing scheduled for March 20-21 in Van Nuys, spurred by new evidence and public attention from the Netflix series “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story.” Without the prosecution’s backing, their chances of release hinge solely on the judge’s ruling, a daunting prospect after years of legal battles.
The case, one of America’s most infamous, began when the brothers gunned down their parents in their Beverly Hills mansion, firing over 14 shots. Initially claiming a mob hit, they were arrested in 1990 after Erik confessed to his therapist. Their televised trials in the 1990s captivated the nation, with the defense arguing self-defense against years of sexual and psychological abuse by Jose Menendez, a powerful entertainment executive, while prosecutors painted a picture of greed-driven murder for a multimillion-dollar inheritance. After a hung jury in 1993, a second trial in 1996 convicted them of first-degree murder with no parole option. Hochman’s latest move reignites a polarizing debate, pitting the brothers’ claims of trauma against accusations of calculated deception.
Hochman, who took office in December 2024 after defeating Gascón in an election, insists the Menendez brothers must “take full responsibility” for their actions, dismissing their self-defense narrative as a fabrication. The Menendez family, rallied under the Justice for Erik and Lyle coalition, accuses the prosecutor of ignoring their trauma and rehabilitation over 35 years behind bars. Defense attorney Mark Geragos fired back, asserting that Lyle and Erik have already confessed to all relevant lies during extensive questioning, urging a focus on their transformation rather than past disputes. As the hearing nears, the case remains a flashpoint in discussions about justice, abuse, and redemption.
Los Angeles shift: prosecutor’s U-turn stuns supporters
Nathan Hochman’s March 10 announcement blindsided advocates for the Menendez brothers. Speaking at a press conference, he outlined his demand: the brothers must confess to all 20 lies he alleges they’ve maintained since 1989, or the resentencing motion—previously filed by Gascón to reduce their sentence to 50 years—will be dropped. Hochman cited examples like their initial claim of a mafia hit and the assertion that their parents planned to kill them that night, arguing only 4 of these falsehoods have been admitted.
This stance marks a sharp departure from Gascón’s approach, who saw the Menendez case as a chance for criminal justice reform. Gascón’s motion, submitted just before his electoral loss, leaned on the brothers’ rehabilitation—evidenced by college degrees and prison programs they founded—potentially paving the way for parole eligibility at ages 57 and 54. Hochman, however, insists their failure to fully own up to the crime’s extent undermines their case. While he left room for reconsideration if they comply, the move leaves Judge Michael Jesic to decide the resentencing fate alone, a tougher road for the defense.
The timing adds pressure. With the hearing just days away, Hochman’s decision shifts the burden entirely to the Menendez legal team, who must now convince the court without prosecutorial support. Family members and supporters, who’ve campaigned tirelessly since new evidence emerged in 2023, expressed outrage, accusing Hochman of stalling a process that had gained momentum after years of stagnation.
Decades in prison: the Menendez brothers’ journey
Lyle and Erik Menendez have spent over 35 years incarcerated since their 1990 arrest. After their 1996 conviction, they were housed in separate California prisons until 2018, when they reunited at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego. There, they’ve built reputations as model inmates, earning degrees—Lyle in sociology, Erik in business—and launching initiatives like the “Healing Trauma” program to support fellow prisoners with abuse histories.
Recent developments had fueled hope. In May 2023, their attorneys filed a habeas corpus petition with two key pieces of evidence: a 1988 letter from Erik to his cousin Andy Cano detailing Jose’s alleged abuse, and testimony from Roy Rosselló, a former Menudo member, claiming Jose abused him in the 1980s. These bolstered the defense’s long-standing argument that the murders stemmed from fear, not greed. Yet, Hochman dismissed the evidence in February 2025 as inadmissible or unreliable, a stance that hardened with his latest announcement.
Family support has grown, though not unanimously. Milton Andersen, Kitty’s brother and a vocal critic who died in March 2025 at 91, long opposed their release, calling the killings premeditated. His passing left the Justice for Erik and Lyle coalition—comprising cousins and aunts—as the dominant familial voice, advocating for their freedom based on their trauma and rehabilitation.
Legal showdown: prosecution clashes with defense
Nathan Hochman’s demand for a full confession has sparked a heated clash with the Menendez defense. He argues their self-defense story is a decades-long “fabrication,” pointing to premeditation evidence like the purchase of shotguns with fake IDs days before the crime and the removal of shell casings to erase fingerprints. Hochman insists that admitting only 4 of 20 lies—such as staging the scene as a mob hit—falls short of the accountability required for resentencing.
Mark Geragos, the brothers’ attorney, hit back hard. Speaking to TMZ, he called Hochman “misinformed” and claimed Lyle and Erik endured weeks of questioning, owning up to all pertinent falsehoods during the original trials. Geragos accused the prosecutor of fixating on the past instead of their exemplary prison records, noting Lyle’s work with hospice care and Erik’s mentorship programs. The defense sees Hochman’s stance as a political play, leveraging his tough-on-crime campaign promises.
The Justice for Erik and Lyle coalition amplified the criticism. In a statement, they accused Hochman of “holding the brothers and family hostage,” arguing he’s dismissing documented abuse and their post-conviction growth. Tensions peaked when cousin Tamara Goodell filed a formal complaint against Hochman, alleging he was “hostile and disrespectful” during a January 2025 family meeting, deepening the rift as the hearing looms.
Roads to release: options on the table
Beyond resentencing, the Menendez brothers pursue multiple paths to freedom. One is a clemency request submitted to California Governor Gavin Newsom in 2024. In February 2025, Newsom ordered a 90-day risk assessment by the parole board to evaluate their threat to society, with results expected to shape his final call. He’s signaled he’ll wait for Hochman’s ultimate position, complicating the timeline.
The 2023 habeas corpus petition offers another route, seeking a new trial based on the Cano letter and Rosselló’s testimony. Hochman rejected this in February 2025, arguing the evidence doesn’t alter the 1996 verdict’s core facts. Without his support, the defense faces an uphill battle to persuade the court to reopen the case, a process that could drag on for months or years.
The March 20-21 hearing remains pivotal. Even with the prosecution’s withdrawal, Judge Jesic could still grant resentencing based on the brothers’ prison conduct and defense arguments. Legal analysts say Hochman’s absence from the motion weakens their odds, but public pressure and family advocacy might sway the outcome.
Case timeline: key moments in the Menendez saga
Spanning over three decades, the Menendez case is a legal odyssey. Here’s a breakdown of major events:
- August 20, 1989: Lyle and Erik kill Jose and Kitty Menendez in Beverly Hills.
- March 1990: Erik’s confession to his therapist triggers their arrest.
- 1993: First trial ends with hung juries.
- 1996: Second trial convicts them of first-degree murder.
- May 2023: Habeas corpus filed with new abuse evidence.
- October 2024: Gascón seeks resentencing to 50 years.
- March 10, 2025: Hochman pulls resentencing motion.
This timeline underscores the case’s complexity, shifting from a sensational murder to a battle over justice and redemption.
Lies under scrutiny: what Hochman wants confessed
Hochman identified 20 lies he claims the Menendez brothers told to mask their crime, insisting on full admission. They’ve acknowledged 4, leaving 16 in dispute. Examples include:
- Staging the murder as a mafia hit, debunked by Erik’s confession.
- Claiming their parents were standing or moving, contradicted by forensic evidence showing them seated or fallen.
- Asserting they feared death during a fishing trip the day before.
- Urging Lyle’s girlfriend to say Jose abused her.
Hochman argues these falsehoods, paired with premeditation signs like the shotgun purchase, dismantle their self-defense claim. The defense counters that the focus should shift to the abuse and their 35-year transformation, not a rehash of old narratives.
Family divide: voices for and against
The Menendez family has been split since the crime, but support for Lyle and Erik has solidified. The Justice for Erik and Lyle coalition, led by cousins and aunts, insists they’re no longer the troubled youths of 1989, citing their trauma and prison contributions like Erik’s “Healing Trauma” program. They see Hochman’s stance as punitive and dismissive.
Milton Andersen, Kitty’s brother, was the outlier until his death in March 2025 at 91. He branded the murder “cold and calculated,” rejecting abuse claims and fearing for family safety if they were freed. His passing shifted the family dynamic, but Hochman, who met over 20 relatives in January 2025, upheld his hardline view.
Tamara Goodell escalated the fight, filing a complaint against Hochman for alleged hostility during the January meeting. She accused him of belittling their pain and showing bias against Geragos, fueling a bitter standoff as the legal clock ticks.






