Guardiola slams Matheus Nunes as midfielder: ‘Not smart enough’ for City’s core

Manchester City’s goalless draw against Manchester United last Sunday, in the 31st round of the Premier League, reignited discussions about Matheus Nunes’ role in the squad. Deployed as a right-back by Pep Guardiola, the Portuguese-Brazilian player, originally a midfielder, faced sharp criticism from the manager regarding his ability to perform in the center of the pitch. Following Rodri’s injury, a key figure in City’s midfield, Nunes was tested in the Spaniard’s position but failed to impress Guardiola, who opted to reposition him on the flank. The Spaniard’s post-match remark that Nunes “is not smart enough” to play in midfield sparked debates about the 26-year-old’s future at the club and his adaptability within a star-studded roster.
Signed in 2023 for £60 million (approximately $76 million at the time), Matheus Nunes arrived at Manchester City with high expectations of bolstering the midfield. His journey through Sporting in Portugal and Wolverhampton in England showcased a dynamic, physically imposing player—traits that caught City’s eye. This season, however, has been one of adjustment, with Nunes featuring in 26 matches, scoring twice, and providing four assists. Though his stats are modest, his stint as a right-back against United earned praise from Guardiola, who sees potential in the new role, despite ruling him out as a midfield option.
Rodri’s absence since September last year forced Manchester City into tactical reshuffling, exposing vulnerabilities in their lineup. With Ilkay Gündogan and Mateo Kovacic stepping up in the middle, Nunes found himself on the sidelines of his natural position, eventually transitioning to the right flank. The stalemate at Old Trafford underlined City’s struggle to regain their usual dominance, yet it also spotlighted Nunes’ willingness to adapt. Playing all 90 minutes against a fierce rival, he held his own, hinting at a possible long-term shift in his career trajectory.
Guardiola’s blunt assessment
Pep Guardiola is known for his candid evaluations, and Matheus Nunes was no exception after the Manchester United clash. “He can become a good right-back because of his physicality. I don’t think he’s a player to play in the middle because he’s not smart enough and lacks the composure needed,” Guardiola stated in a post-match interview. The comment, delivered with his trademark directness, underscored his vision for Nunes while raising eyebrows among fans and pundits alike.
Yet, Guardiola didn’t shy away from praising Nunes’ efforts on the flank. Facing United’s Bruno Fernandes and Rasmus Højlund, the Portuguese player showcased defensive tenacity, thwarting multiple crosses. “He defended two or three crosses from Bruno Fernandes and Dorgu very well,” Guardiola noted, highlighting Nunes’ physical edge and growing comfort in the role. This duality—criticism of his midfield instincts paired with approval of his lateral play—paints a complex picture of a player still finding his footing at the Etihad Stadium.
The £60 million investment in Nunes now hangs in the balance. At 26, with a contract running until 2028, he has time to carve out a niche, but Guardiola’s words suggest a ceiling on his midfield aspirations. His stint at Wolverhampton, where he played 34 games and scored once in the 2022-2023 season, hinted at versatility, yet City’s tactical demands appear to require more than he’s currently offering in the center. For now, the right-back experiment seems a pragmatic fix, but it leaves open questions about his long-term value to the squad.
Nunes’ path to Manchester City
Born in Rio de Janeiro, Matheus Nunes moved to Portugal as a young boy, laying the foundation for his football career. His breakout came at Sporting, where he clinched the Portuguese league title in 2020-2021, amassing 101 appearances, eight goals, and 15 assists. That form earned him a £38 million ($48 million) move to Wolverhampton in 2022, where he adapted to the Premier League’s intensity. A year later, Manchester City swooped in, betting big on his potential to thrive in their system.
Rodri’s injury last September thrust Nunes into the spotlight as a possible replacement. Early tests against Arsenal and Newcastle saw him deployed as a holding midfielder, but his performances lacked the precision and awareness Rodri brought to the role. Guardiola soon pivoted, handing the midfield reins to Gündogan and Kovacic while nudging Nunes toward the right flank. The shift reflects both the player’s physical gifts and the manager’s unrelenting standards for midfielders in his setup.
Adjusting to the Premier League has been a steep learning curve for Nunes. The league’s pace and physicality demand quick thinking—qualities he’s still honing. His Brazilian roots and Portuguese flair add flair to his game, but Guardiola’s critique suggests a gap in tactical acumen that could define his City tenure. As he settles into the right-back role, fans watch closely, curious if this adaptation will stick or if it’s merely a stopgap.
Why Nunes ended up at right-back
Guardiola’s choice to deploy Matheus Nunes as a right-back stemmed from necessity and strategy. Rodri’s injury left a void in midfield, and Nunes, with his stamina and athleticism, seemed a logical fill-in. However, his struggles to dictate play and maintain composure prompted a rethink. Against Manchester United, the move paid off defensively, with Nunes neutralizing threats down his flank and leveraging his speed to track back effectively.
The switch also addressed a shortage at full-back. With Kyle Walker on loan at Milan since January and youngster Rico Lewis still maturing, City needed options. Nunes’ physical profile—tall, fast, and relentless—fit the bill, even if his lack of positional experience showed at times. Guardiola praised his ability to handle crosses, a recurring issue for full-backs, but the experiment’s success hinges on refining his defensive instincts.
Historically, Guardiola thrives on such improvisation. João Cancelo and Oleksandr Zinchenko thrived in unconventional roles under him, and Nunes could follow suit. For now, his lateral stint buys City time as they navigate a season of upheaval, but it’s clear the manager sees his physicality as a better fit on the edge than in the engine room.
Nunes’ stats this season
Matheus Nunes’ numbers at Manchester City tell a story of contribution and compromise. In 26 appearances, including 18 starts, he’s logged 1,620 minutes, scoring two goals and assisting four times. Defensively, he averages 1.2 tackles per game and wins 56% of his duels—figures that have ticked up since moving to right-back. His pass accuracy sits at 85%, a solid mark, though it pales next to Rodri’s elite standards.
Compared to teammates, Nunes lags behind. Kevin De Bruyne, despite a dip in form, has five assists in fewer games, while Rodri’s all-around impact remains unmatched. Yet, in his last five outings as a right-back, Nunes added two assists, hinting at untapped potential. At Wolverhampton, he enjoyed more freedom to roam; at City, the system demands precision he’s yet to master fully. The stats suggest a player in transition, adapting to survive in a high-stakes environment.
Fan and analyst reactions
Guardiola’s remarks on Nunes split the fanbase. On social media, some City supporters agreed he’s out of his depth in midfield, citing sloppy passes and positional lapses. Others rallied behind him, valuing his hustle and flexibility. “He’s not Rodri, but he’s trying,” one fan tweeted, while another quipped, “If he’s not smart, why’d we spend £60 million?” The debate rages as fans weigh his effort against his price tag.
Analysts see Guardiola’s move as vintage pragmatism. Parallels with João Cancelo abound—both players shifted roles to stay relevant—though Nunes leans on power over finesse. Pundits note City’s broader struggles, with De Bruyne’s looming exit and Rodri’s absence exposing cracks. For some, Guardiola’s jab at Nunes’ intelligence is a motivational tactic; for others, it’s a red flag on his ceiling at the club.
The Flamengo family factor
Off the pitch, Matheus Nunes draws strength from his Brazilian heritage. Raised in Rio by a Flamengo-obsessed family, he credits their passion for fueling his drive. “My whole family is Flamengo, so that energy pushes me in big games,” he shared recently. Though he chose Portugal internationally, where he’s played 15 times and scored twice, his carioca roots resonate with City’s Brazilian fans.
That Flamengo fervor could bolster Nunes amid Guardiola’s critique. Growing up steeped in football culture, even from afar, built resilience he’ll need at City. Supporters in Brazil have latched onto this backstory, joking he might channel some rubro-negro grit to prove his worth in Manchester.
City’s woes without Rodri
Rodri’s September injury rocked Manchester City. The Spaniard’s 87% pass accuracy, 2.5 tackles per game, and game-controlling presence are irreplaceable, and his absence has forced adjustments. Nunes’ midfield audition flopped, paving the way for Gündogan’s return to prominence and Kovacic’s steady hand. The United draw, with its lack of spark, underscored how vital Rodri is to City’s rhythm.
De Bruyne’s planned departure at season’s end compounds the issue. At 33, the Belgian leaves behind a legacy of six Premier League titles and a Champions League crown. Without these linchpins, City faces a rebuild, and Nunes’ right-back cameo might be a piece of that puzzle—if he can rise to the occasion.
Nunes versus Guardiola’s past projects
Guardiola’s knack for repositioning players is well-documented. João Cancelo morphed from full-back to playmaker, while Zinchenko flipped from midfielder to left-back. Even De Bruyne dropped deeper at times. Nunes fits this mold, though his raw athleticism sets him apart from the technical wizards who came before. His 1.8 successful dribbles per game outpace Cancelo’s 1.2 in his final City season, but he trails in key passes.
Against Kyle Walker, Nunes holds his own in pace but lacks the veteran’s savvy. Walker’s loan to Milan opened the door, and Nunes must now marry his vigor with sharper defending. Guardiola’s track record suggests success is possible, but the clock’s ticking for Nunes to prove he belongs.
What lies ahead for Nunes
With a deal until 2028, Matheus Nunes has room to grow, yet Guardiola’s verdict looms large. At 26, he’s at a career crossroads: master the right-back role or risk fading into the background. Gündogan and Kovacic hold the midfield, and rumors of Florian Wirtz joining to replace De Bruyne could squeeze Nunes further. His versatility is an asset, but without a fixed spot, he might face a transfer down the line.
Upcoming matches against Brighton and Bournemouth offer a stage to shine. If Nunes builds on his United showing, he could cement a role in City’s future. Falter, and his £60 million tag might not save him from an early exit.
Quick facts about Nunes
Here’s a glimpse into Matheus Nunes’ background:
- Born in Rio de Janeiro, he moved to Portugal at age 12.
- He worked in his family’s Lisbon bakery before going pro.
- Debuted for Portugal in 2021, with 15 caps and two goals.
- A Flamengo fan by family tradition, he’s never played in Brazil professionally.
These tidbits highlight a journey of grit and adaptation, mirroring his current City chapter.
Nunes’ right-back potential
Switching positions mid-career is daunting, but Nunes shows promise. His United outing brought stability, and his stamina stood out in a gritty draw. Guardiola’s drills focus on fixing full-back flaws—like second-post awareness—and Nunes is responding. Blending his power with tactical nous could turn him into a City mainstay, especially as the squad evolves post-De Bruyne.
Fans hope he seizes this lifeline. With reinforcements likely incoming, Nunes must excel now to secure his spot. Whether he thrives or fades, his next steps will define his Manchester City legacy.






