Disney and Universal accuse AI firm of plagiarizing iconic characters in generated images

On Wednesday, June 11, 2025, entertainment giants Walt Disney and Universal Studios filed a lawsuit against Midjourney, an artificial intelligence company specializing in image generation, for copyright infringement. The case, lodged in the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, marks the first major legal action by Hollywood studios against a generative AI firm. The complaint alleges that Midjourney used copyrighted works without permission to train its algorithms, producing images that replicate iconic characters like Darth Vader from Star Wars and the Minions from Despicable Me. Described as a response to “blatant piracy,” the lawsuit seeks an injunction to halt ongoing violations and unspecified damages. This move underscores the growing tension between the entertainment industry and advancing AI technologies, raising questions about the boundaries of using protected content.
Midjourney, founded in 2021 by David Holz, is renowned for its platform that converts text prompts into detailed images, attracting millions of users and generating approximately $300 million in revenue last year. Despite its popularity, the company faces criticism for training its models with data scraped from the internet, often without compensating original creators. Disney and Universal claim Midjourney ignored prior requests to stop using their intellectual properties, escalating the dispute.
The 110-page lawsuit details examples of Midjourney-generated images featuring characters like Yoda, Buzz Lightyear, and Homer Simpson. The studios accuse the AI firm of acting as a “copyright parasite,” profiting without investing in the creation of these works.
- Involved characters: Darth Vader, Elsa, Minions, Shrek, among others.
- Primary demand: Immediate ban on using protected works.
- Midjourney’s revenue: $300 million in 2024, per the studios.
- User base: Around 21 million as of September 2024.
Pioneering action in entertainment
The decision by Disney and Universal to sue Midjourney sets a precedent in the entertainment industry. Until now, lawsuits against generative AI companies were primarily led by authors, visual artists, record labels, and news organizations, such as The New York Times, which sued OpenAI for similar practices. Major Hollywood studios had largely stayed out of these disputes, drawing criticism from writers’ and creators’ unions.
This lawsuit signals a shift. The Writers Guild of America, for instance, had been urging executives like Disney’s Bob Iger to act against what they call “intellectual property theft” by AI firms. The joint action by two companies controlling billion-dollar franchises may encourage others in the industry to follow suit, potentially broadening the scope of litigation.
The studios’ move comes amid growing concerns about AI’s impact on creative industries. While some see potential for collaboration, the lack of clear regulations has fueled conflicts.
Midjourney’s business model
Midjourney operates on a subscription model, with plans ranging from $10 to $120 per month, allowing users to create and download AI-generated images. Based in San Francisco, the company relies on vast amounts of visual data to train its algorithms but does not publicly disclose the sources of this data.
David Holz, Midjourney’s CEO, has likened the platform’s functionality to a “search engine” that aggregates publicly available images. In a 2022 interview, he argued that machine learning mirrors how humans draw inspiration from others’ work, suggesting the practice is protected under the “fair use” doctrine in U.S. copyright law.
- Subscription plans: $10 to $120 per month.
- Founded: Established in 2021, launched in 2022.
- Defense: Claims “fair use” for AI training.
- Criticism: Lack of transparency on data sources.
Disney and Universal dismiss this argument, labeling Midjourney’s actions as “calculated and intentional infringement.”
Characters at the heart of the dispute
The lawsuit lists numerous characters allegedly reproduced by Midjourney. Beyond Star Wars figures like Darth Vader and Yoda, it includes characters from Frozen (Elsa, Olaf), Toy Story (Buzz Lightyear), and The Simpsons (Homer, Bart). From Universal, Shrek, the Minions, and characters from How to Train Your Dragon are cited.
According to the complaint, Midjourney’s images not only copy visual traits but also recreate scenes and contexts tied to these characters, strengthening the plagiarism claim. One example is an image of Yoda wielding a lightsaber, replicating specific Star Wars elements.
These characters are no random choice. Disney and Universal argue they form part of a cultural and economic legacy built over decades, with significant investments in creation, production, and marketing. Unauthorized reproduction, they claim, devalues this legacy and threatens the film industry, which employs millions and generates over $260 billion annually in the U.S.
Industry reactions
The lawsuit sparked immediate reactions in the entertainment sector. Creative professionals, including writers and animators, voiced support, viewing it as a step toward protecting their work from indiscriminate use by AI technologies. Unions like the Writers Guild of America West emphasized the need for clear regulations on using protected content in algorithm training.
Conversely, tech innovation advocates argue that generative AI can coexist with creative industries if licensing or compensation agreements are established. However, companies like Midjourney have shown little interest in negotiating with copyright holders, intensifying conflicts.
The “fair use” debate
A core issue in the lawsuit is the interpretation of the “fair use” doctrine in U.S. copyright law. AI companies, including Midjourney, argue that using protected content to train algorithms is permissible if the output is transformative and not a direct copy.
Disney and Universal counter that Midjourney’s images are faithful reproductions of their characters, directly violating copyright. The case could set significant precedents for defining “fair use” in the AI context, potentially shaping future regulations.
- Fair use definition: Allows limited use of protected works without permission.
- Studios’ argument: Midjourney’s images are copies, not transformations.
- Potential outcome: Precedent for AI-related disputes.
Other industry disputes
The action against Midjourney is not unique. Recent years have seen similar lawsuits against AI firms. The New York Times sued OpenAI, while Getty Images took Stability AI to court in London. These cases highlight growing concerns about how AI technologies use protected content.
Midjourney’s case is amplified by its large user base and the high quality of its generated images, which directly compete with original productions. Disney and Universal warn that, without judicial intervention, Midjourney’s business model could encourage other firms to adopt similar practices.
Midjourney’s response
As of now, Midjourney has not issued an official response to the lawsuit. Representatives were unavailable for comment, according to Reuters and CNBC. This silence contrasts with the severity of the accusations, which label the company a “bottomless pit of plagiarism.”
The company is expected to defend itself by invoking “fair use” and the transformative nature of its images. However, the compelling evidence presented by Disney and Universal, including screenshots of generated images, may complicate its strategy.
The road ahead legally
The lawsuit is likely to extend for months, with initial hearings scheduled for late 2025. The studios are seeking an urgent injunction to stop Midjourney from generating images based on their properties, alongside damages.
The case may also push lawmakers to establish clearer rules for generative AI. In the U.S., Congress is debating proposals to regulate the industry, but consensus remains elusive.
Safeguarding a legacy
The lawsuit underscores Disney and Universal’s commitment to protecting their intellectual properties, which extend beyond characters to encompass films, theme parks, and licensed products. Unauthorized reproduction of figures like Elsa or Shrek threatens not only revenue but also the cultural identity of these brands.
The studios stress that while AI technology holds promise, it cannot justify violating intellectual property laws. “Piracy is piracy, regardless of the technology used,” said Horacio Gutierrez, Disney’s executive vice president, in a statement.






