Collective action against FIFA could compensate 100,000 players in Europe

The Dutch foundation Justice for Players has launched a collective lawsuit against FIFA and European national football federations, accusing transfer rules of violating the rights of approximately 100,000 players who have played in the European Union and the United Kingdom since 2002. Announced on August 4, 2025, the case is being heard in the Midden-Nederland District Court in the Netherlands, seeking compensation for salary losses estimated at up to 8%. Inspired by the Lassana Diarra case, ruled on in 2024 by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), the lawsuit claims FIFA’s rules restrict athletes’ freedom and cause financial harm. The initiative could reshape the European football transfer market.
The Diarra case exposed flaws in FIFA’s rules, which prevented the French player from transferring from Lokomotiv Moscow to Charleroi, Belgium, in 2015, while also demanding compensation. The CJEU ruled that these regulations violate European laws on free movement. Justice for Players now represents athletes of all levels, from top-tier to lower divisions.
- Key points of the lawsuit:
- Involves players and former players since 2002.
- Based on the precedent set by the Lassana Diarra case.
- Seeks compensation for salary losses of up to 8%.
- Accuses FIFA of violating competition laws.
The collective action could lead to billion-dollar compensations and force changes in transfer regulations, impacting clubs, players, and federations.
Origin of the Diarra case
The Lassana Diarra case, ruled on in October 2024 by the CJEU, is the legal foundation for the collective lawsuit. Diarra faced FIFA sanctions after terminating his contract with Lokomotiv Moscow in 2014 due to salary cuts imposed by the club. FIFA ordered him to pay €10.5 million and denied the International Transfer Certificate (ITC), blocking his move to Charleroi. The CJEU declared that Article 17 of FIFA’s Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) violates the principle of free movement of workers in Europe.
The ruling highlighted that FIFA’s rules create financial and sporting barriers, limiting player mobility. Justice for Players uses this precedent to argue that thousands of athletes have suffered similar losses over two decades.
- Details of the Diarra case:
- Transfer ban to Charleroi in 2015.
- €10.5 million compensation demanded by FIFA.
- CJEU’s 2024 ruling against FIFA’s rules.
- Recognition of violation of free competition.
This precedent paved the way for challenging the legality of the transfer system, encouraging the collective lawsuit.
"Enough is enough, we can't take it anymore" 😤
— Sky Sports News (@SkySportsNews) October 14, 2024
The World Players' Union (FIFPRO) and the European leagues' group have filed a legal complaint to the European commission, accusing FIFA of abuse of power and a conflict of interest 📑 pic.twitter.com/wHSWPsZoby
Financial losses for players
An analysis by the consultancy Compass Lexecon, cited by Justice for Players, estimates that FIFA’s transfer rules have caused salary losses of about 8% for players in Europe. These losses stem from restrictions that hinder transfers, particularly for athletes with short-term contracts or in lower divisions, who have less negotiating power.
Younger players face additional barriers, with fewer opportunities to advance their careers. The collective lawsuit seeks to compensate for these losses, which could total billions of euros, considering the 100,000 athletes potentially involved.
- Financial impacts of FIFA’s rules:
- 8% salary reduction due to transfer barriers.
- Lower mobility for lower-division players.
- Short-term contracts limit bargaining power.
- Losses accumulated since 2002 in the EU and UK.
The foundation argues that FIFA must compensate athletes and reform its rules to ensure greater market fairness.
FIFA’s response to the allegations
In response to the CJEU’s ruling in the Diarra case, FIFA announced in December 2024 a provisional regulatory framework to align the RSTP with European laws. The changes include clearer criteria for contract terminations, revised compensation rules, and adjustments to ITC issuance. However, Justice for Players considers these measures insufficient, demanding reparations for damages since 2002.
FIFA stated it will analyze the collective lawsuit with other stakeholders but argued that only two paragraphs of the RSTP were challenged by the CJEU. Experts, however, believe the legal pressure could force broader changes.
- FIFA’s actions post-Diarra case:
- Revision of Article 17 of the RSTP.
- Definition of criteria for just cause in terminations.
- Adjustments to International Transfer Certificate issuance.
- Reduction of financial risks for hiring clubs.
The legal pressure may compel FIFA to adopt more significant reforms in the transfer system.
Dutch court as the battleground
The lawsuit is being heard in the Netherlands due to the Collective Damages Settlement Act, which allows actions on behalf of large groups. The Midden-Nederland District Court will evaluate the claims, which include compensation for players who have played in the EU and UK since 2002. The law firm Dupont-Hissel, led by Jean-Louis Dupont, known for the Bosman case, is advising Justice for Players.
The Bosman case in 1995 revolutionized football by allowing free transfers at the end of contracts. The current lawsuit could have a similar impact, questioning FIFA’s termination and compensation rules.
- Features of the Dutch lawsuit:
- Supported by the Collective Damages Settlement Act.
- Represents up to 100,000 players.
- Led by lawyer Jean-Louis Dupont.
- Estimates of billion-dollar compensations.
The Dutch court will be pivotal in shaping the future of football transfers.
Effects on the transfer market
The collective lawsuit could transform the European transfer market. The CJEU’s ruling already indicated that FIFA’s rules violate competition laws, and a favorable verdict for the players could ease contract terminations and increase mobility. Smaller clubs may benefit, but there are risks of market imbalance, with larger clubs attracting more talent.
Unions like FIFPro support the lawsuit, advocating for greater player rights protection. Regulatory changes could strengthen athletes’ positions but challenge smaller clubs reliant on compensation.
- Potential market impacts:
- Greater freedom for players to negotiate contracts.
- Reduced barriers to international transfers.
- Benefits for smaller clubs in hiring.
- Financial risks for youth-developing clubs.
The case reignites discussions on football governance, with potential for lasting changes.
Next steps in the lawsuit
The Dutch court case may take years but is already impacting European football. Justice for Players hopes the lawsuit will compel FIFA to compensate athletes and adopt fairer rules. The Diarra precedent strengthens the players’ position, while pressure from unions and club associations grows.
Clubs and federations are closely monitoring the case, aware that the outcome could redefine the transfer market. The collective lawsuit marks a critical moment for football, with potential to address historical inequities.






