Elon Musk warns of the risk of comet 3I/ATLAS colliding with Earth in an interview

Elon Musk, CEO of SpaceX, stated in an interview with the podcast The Joe Rogan Experience, on October 31, 2025, that the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS represents an extreme risk if it collides with Earth. The object, detected in July 2025 by the ATLAS system in Chile, is the third confirmed visitor from outside the Solar System, after ‘Oumuamua and Borisov. Musk ruled out hypotheses of artificial origin, classifying it as a natural comet, but highlighted its speed of 57 km/s and estimated size between 440 meters and 5.6 km.
The discussion arose from online speculation about 3I/ATLAS, which reached perihelion on October 30, 2025, 210 million kilometers from the Sun. Despite its hyperbolic trajectory taking it out of the Solar System without impact, Musk emphasized the devastating potential in a hypothetical scenario. He explained that variations in the route result from the release of gases, common in comets heated by the Sun.
The comet approaches Earth on December 19, 2025, at 270 million kilometers, allowing detailed observations by global telescopes.
- Detected on July 1, 2025 by ATLAS.
- Third interstellar object confirmed.
- Composition includes cyanide and nickel, typical of comets.
- Early activity suggests volatiles such as CO₂ and CO.
Trajectory and initial observations
3I/ATLAS came into scientific focus due to its eccentric orbit, which indicates its origin in another star system. Observations from the Space Telescopeal Hubble on July 21, 2025 revealed a marginal coma and tail elongation of 3 arc seconds. NASA and ESO researchers confirmed cometary streaks on July 2.
These data position the object as a “time capsule” of the Milky Way, with billions of years of travel. The velocity and dust cross-section of 230 km² facilitate spectral analysis.

Speculations on non-gravitational accelerations
Avi Loeb, an astronomer at Harvard, pointed out accelerations compatible with outgassing on his blog. This release of gases by sublimation of ice changes the trajectory without the need for external forces.
Musk refuted ideas of intentional maneuvers, stating that such effects occur in common comets. VLT observations on August 14 detected cyanide, reinforcing the natural nature.
SETI monitored the object but ruled out artificial signals. Images of China near Mars in October 2025 showed collimated jets, with no evidence of technology.
Chemical composition and detected metals
Atomic nickel in 3I/ATLAS sparked debate, but Musk clarified that metals such as nickel and cobalt are abundant in asteroids and comets. Node land deposits�which result from ancient impacts of these bodies.
Spectra indicate ultraviolet unstable nickel tetracarbonyl, common in space environments. Loeb mentioned anomalies, but comparative studies with 2I/Borisov show natural consistency.
Reactions from the astronomical community
SETI and NASA astronomers have rejected artificial origins since July. Franck Marchis, from the SETI Institute, highlighted perihelion as an opportunity for future missions like Comet Interceptor.
Loeb attributed a 30-40% chance to unnaturalness, but evidence prioritizes conventional explanations. Post-perihelion observations on November 5, 2025 showed a compact source with no clear tail, consistent with 13% mass loss.
The event prepares agencies for interstellar intercepts.
Impact hypothesis and scale of damage
Musk described a collision as capable of obliterating an entire continent. Its mass could extinguish most of humanity, depending on the composition.
The current orbit eliminates any real risk. Solar conjugation on October 21, 2025 limited observations, but data from Europa Clipper and Hera captured ion-tail interactions.
Studies predict magnetic structures draped by the solar wind.
Preparations for land approach
Worldwide telescopes track 3I/ATLAS for high-resolution imagesin December. The retrograde inclination of the orbit facilitates access, but without threats.
Missions like Hera will immerse themselves in the ion tail between October 25 and November 1, 2025. This data calibrates models for interstellar objects. The object reinforces surveillance against cosmic threats, without evidence of hostile intentions.






