US unlikely to replicate Venezuela offensive in Latin America, Garman asserts amidst 2025 strategic priorities

A direct military offensive by the United States against other Latin American nations, similar to the recent operation in Venezuela, is highly improbable, according to Christopher Garman, executive director for the Americas at Eurasia Group. Despite assertive rhetoric from former President Donald Trump, the geopolitical landscapes and bilateral relationships across the region present significantly different scenarios than those observed in Venezuela. This assessment, made in 2025, highlights a nuanced approach to Washington’s regional strategy, balancing threats with pragmatic diplomacy and economic interests.
The Venezuela operation, which saw the capture of former dictator Nicolás Maduro, served as a stark example of a specific type of intervention. This action against a leader widely considered isolated and lacking significant domestic public support, was unique. However, its characteristics are unlikely to be replicated as a template for broader military engagements across the continent, even as the US maintains a heightened strategic focus on Latin America.
Different regional dynamics temper military action
Even with former President Trump’s past warnings to countries like Mexico and Colombia, the conditions in these nations substantially differ from the isolated context of Venezuela. Trump previously alleged, without substantiation, that drug cartels controlled Mexican territory rather than the government, despite maintaining good dialogue with President Claudia Sheinbaum. Similarly, he cautioned Colombian leader Gustavo Petro to “get smart,” hinting at potential military action.
However, Garman suggests that actual military intervention in these cases is difficult to envision. Upcoming elections in Colombia, for instance, are anticipated to bring a right-wing government into power, potentially altering the political dynamic. Furthermore, the established relationship between President Sheinbaum and Trump, cultivated over the past year, provides a buffer against aggressive actions.
Mexico and Colombia’s distinct scenarios
The diplomatic channels and political environments in Mexico and Colombia present significant hurdles for any direct military intervention. Mexico’s robust economy and complex relationship with the U.S. demand a more measured approach, despite rhetorical flourishes from Washington. The Sheinbaum-Trump dialogue has proven to be a stabilizing factor, focusing on shared interests and border management.
In Colombia, the political transition expected in 2025 through national elections introduces another layer of complexity. A shift towards a right-leaning administration could align more closely with certain U.S. policy objectives, reducing the perceived need for drastic measures. These internal political trajectories are crucial considerations for Washington, outweighing the impetus for military force.
Both nations also possess varying degrees of international support and regional alliances, making unilateral military action by the US a more complicated and potentially costly endeavor. The diplomatic fallout and regional instability resulting from such moves would be substantial, deterring rapid intervention.
US strategic priorities beyond direct intervention
While direct military intervention may be less likely, Washington continues to view the region as a strategic priority, as evidenced by its actions and policy documents. The attack on Venezuela is part of a broader framework of American actions designed to reinforce its influence and address perceived threats, even if these do not involve overt military offensives. This strategic outlook is explicitly articulated in the National Strategic Security (NSS) document, which emphasizes maintaining US control over the continent.
Since former President Trump’s return to the White House, his administration has actively pursued several strategic initiatives. These include pressuring Panama to reduce China’s presence in the vital Panama Canal and extending credit lines to the Argentine government, reportedly conditioned on the victory of Javier Milei’s party in elections. These actions highlight a multifaceted approach to maintaining influence without resorting to military force.
Brazil’s nuanced relationship with Washington
For Brazil, the immediate impact of this strategic focus is considered more limited, despite recent U.S. tariffs and sanctions against Brazilian officials. A key factor is the mutual interest in critical minerals; the White House desires a cooperation agreement with Brazil on these resources. This aligns with a goal from Brazil’s Planalto Palace to reduce U.S. tariffs imposed in July.
This convergence of interests fosters a more collaborative, albeit occasionally tense, relationship. Discussions around trade and critical resource supply chains are expected to dominate, pushing potential military considerations to the periphery. The economic leverage and strategic importance of Brazil’s natural resources provide a strong incentive for diplomatic engagement over confrontation.
The “Donroe doctrine” and renewed regional focus
Former President Trump has notably termed this strategy the “Donroe doctrine,” a direct reference to the historic Monroe Doctrine, which posited Latin America as being under Washington’s direct influence. This modern interpretation signals a renewed emphasis on asserting U.S. hegemony in the Western Hemisphere, utilizing a blend of economic pressure, diplomatic leverage, and targeted actions rather than widespread military intervention. This doctrine underscores a proactive approach to counter rival influences, particularly from China, and ensure regional stability aligned with U.S. interests. The implementation of the “Donroe doctrine” is designed to maintain strong American influence across Latin America, adapting traditional principles to contemporary geopolitical realities.
Sustained American influence
This evolving approach demonstrates America’s intent to sustain significant influence in Latin America through various non-military means. The strategic actions, economic pressures, and diplomatic engagements collectively underscore Washington’s long-term commitment to shaping regional dynamics and safeguarding its strategic interests without necessarily deploying troops.






