São Paulo court orders Marçal to pay R$100,000 to Boulos for fake news during 2024 election bid

Pablo Marçal, an entrepreneur, has been ordered by a São Paulo court to pay R$100,000 in damages to federal deputy Guilherme Boulos. This ruling stems from the dissemination of false information during the 2024 São Paulo mayoral election campaign.
The judicial decision, issued by Judge Danilo Fadel de Castro on January 29, 2024, found Marçal liable for defamation. He circulated fraudulent claims and a forged medical report linking Boulos to cocaine use and a severe psychotic episode.
This initial verdict is subject to appeal, signaling that the legal battle between the two political figures may continue. The case highlights the judiciary’s stance against deliberate misinformation in political contests.
The roots of the libel case
During the intense 2024 São Paulo mayoral election, Pablo Marçal launched a defamatory campaign against Guilherme Boulos. Marçal explicitly associated Boulos with cocaine use, spreading these serious allegations widely.
Just prior to the first round, Marçal escalated tactics by disseminating a falsified medical report. This document falsely attributed a “severe psychotic outbreak” to Boulos, claiming it resulted from illicit drug consumption.
Fabricated evidence exposed
Judicial investigation involved extensive forensic analysis by the Civil and Federal Police. These expert examinations conclusively proved the medical report to be a complete forgery and a deliberate act of deception.
Further scrutiny revealed a critical detail: the signature on the fraudulent document belonged to a physician already deceased at the time of its alleged creation. This irrefutable evidence underscored the calculated nature of Marçal’s deceit.
Judge Danilo Fadel de Castro condemned the actions, stating: “This is not about opinion, satire, or rhetorical hyperbole. It is the cold and calculated fabrication of a documentary lie to deceive the electorate and destroy the opponent’s honor.”
Court rejects defense’s jurisdictional claim
Marçal’s legal team initially argued the case should be heard by electoral courts, citing events transpired during a political campaign. They posited campaign-related disputes fall exclusively within electoral jurisdiction.
However, the São Paulo court emphatically rejected this. The judge clarified that moral damages actions between candidates, even if occurring during an election, concern personal rights violations, falling under ordinary civil justice.
Setting the indemnity amount
Guilherme Boulos originally sought R$1 million in compensation for reputational damage and distress from the fake news. This aimed to reflect the severe impact of false allegations on his public image.
The court, after considering all aspects, ultimately fixed the indemnity at R$100,000. This decision was based on principles of reasonableness and proportionality inherent in civil law.
The judge explained this sum is “sufficient to reprove the harmful conduct, serving as a warning that the Judiciary will not tolerate the transformation of the political arena into fertile ground for criminality against honor.” It serves both as compensation and a deterrent.
Moreover, the court ensured compensation would not lead to unjust enrichment for Boulos. The R$100,000 figure was deemed appropriate to address moral harm without being excessive.
Beyond the financial penalty
In addition to the R$100,000 award, the court mandated that Pablo Marçal cover all procedural costs. This includes a significant payment for attorney fees, set at 15% of the total condemnation value, further increasing the financial burden on the defendant.
The comprehensive judgment emphasizes the judiciary’s commitment to holding public figures accountable for actions during election campaigns. It reinforces ethical boundaries, highlighting that calculated falsehoods carry serious legal repercussions beyond typical electoral sanctions.
Precedent and ongoing appeals
The São Paulo court’s decision establishes a significant legal precedent regarding the dissemination of fake news and fraudulent documents in Brazilian political campaigns. It unequivocally asserts that such conduct, designed to deceive the electorate and damage an opponent’s reputation, will incur substantial civil penalties, distinct from electoral infractions. This ruling underscores judicial intolerance for dishonest tactics that undermine the democratic process. Despite this strong initial verdict, Marçal retains the right to appeal this first-instance decision to higher courts as of early 2025. The ongoing appeal process means the final legal outcome is still pending, but the foundational judgment sends a powerful message about accountability and the protection of individual honor.
Political landscape reflections
This judgment arrives as discussions about regulating online disinformation, particularly in political contexts, are prominent globally. The court’s firm stance reinforces the importance of factual integrity in public discourse.






