Rapporteur proposes constitutional change to mandate full sentences for feminicide, pedophilia, and gang heads
A significant constitutional amendment regarding public safety, currently under discussion in Brazil’s National Congress, aims to fundamentally alter the application of sentence progression for certain heinous crimes. The rapporteur of the Public Safety Constitutional Amendment Proposal (PEC), Representative Mendonça Filho (União-PE), is set to introduce a provision that would constitutionally allow for the reduction or even elimination of sentence progression for individuals convicted of feminicide and pedophilia, ensuring they serve their full sentences. This initiative extends a similar proposal already on the table concerning leaders of criminal factions, reflecting a broader governmental push for tougher penal enforcement against serious offenses.
Should this amendment be approved, it would provide a robust constitutional basis for future laws seeking to diminish or abolish sentence progression for these specific cases, thereby shielding such legislation from potential judicial challenges or invalidation. The PEC itself does not directly eliminate sentence progression; rather, it creates the legal framework for the Brazilian legislature to enact subsequent laws that would concretize these stricter measures. The practical implication is that lawmakers would then be empowered to vote on bills specifically designed to mandate full sentences for those convicted of feminicide, pedophilia, or involvement in organized crime leadership.
Currently, sentence progression is a fundamental right afforded to all convicted individuals in Brazil, enabling them to transition to less severe prison regimes based on criteria established by law. Judges typically evaluate a prisoner’s eligibility for this benefit by assessing their adherence to legal requirements, as stipulated by judicial bodies like the Federal District and Territories Court of Justice (TSDFT). The Law of Penal Execution further mandates that inmates can only qualify for progression if they demonstrate good conduct within the correctional facility, corroborated by the institution’s director and the findings of a criminological examination.
Understanding the Public Safety PEC in 2025
The Public Safety PEC, originally sponsored by the Executive branch, remains a top legislative priority for President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s (PT) administration in 2025. Its core objective is to elevate the Unified Public Security System (SUSP) to constitutional status, thereby enhancing its authority and permanence. Established in 2018 through ordinary legislation, the SUSP framework seeks to foster greater integration and cooperation among federal, state, and municipal entities in developing and implementing public safety policies across the nation.
This comprehensive proposal represents a focal point of ongoing debates and occasional impasses between the government and opposition factions within the National Congress. Beyond the provisions on sentence progression, the PEC also introduces significant alterations to several critical areas, including the National Public Security Council, the National Public Security Fund, and the National Penitentiary Fund. Furthermore, it addresses operational and structural aspects concerning federal law enforcement agencies such as the Federal Police (PF) and Federal Highway Police (PRF), as well as municipal guards, aiming for a more cohesive national security apparatus.
Anticipated Legislative Progress and Discussions
The Public Safety PEC is projected to see significant advancements within the Chamber of Deputies starting in March 2025. While initial plans aimed for its review in late February, continued discussions between the rapporteur and various party caucuses have necessitated a slightly extended timeline. Parliamentary leaders suggest that a vote within the special commission and subsequent plenary sessions are now more probable for early March, reflecting the intricate nature of the negotiations.
Throughout early 2025, extensive conversations about the proposal’s detailed provisions have taken place with caucus leaders and prominent congressional figures, including Representative Hugo Motta (Republicanos-PB), marking the return of legislative work for the year. The rapporteur has also engaged with government officials, including the current Minister of Justice, Ricardo Lewandowski, to iron out differences. Notably, the government’s allied bench has expressed reservations concerning certain aspects of the text, such as the potential for reducing the age of criminal responsibility, indicating that further negotiation is essential to secure broader support for the bill.
Navigating Concurrent Legislative Priorities
The path forward for the PEC remains intertwined with other critical legislative items, particularly the Anti-Gang Bill, which currently holds constitutional urgency status. This bill, having already been approved by deputies but subsequently modified in the Senate, has returned to the Chamber for further review and is poised to potentially block other legislative agendas in the coming days. The intricate timing creates a strategic challenge for congressional leadership.
From the perspective of Representative Mendonça Filho, the Public Safety PEC should be brought to a vote before the Anti-Gang Bill to ensure its timely progression. However, the final determination regarding the Chamber’s legislative agenda rests with congressional leaders and prominent figures like Hugo Motta, who must balance competing priorities and build consensus. The PEC’s status as a constitutional amendment proposal means it can be voted on even if other bills are blocking the agenda, providing a procedural advantage in its legislative journey.
The Debate on Sentence Progression
The proposed changes to sentence progression for severe crimes have ignited considerable debate among legal experts and human rights advocates. Critics argue that any attempt to eliminate or severely restrict this mechanism could be viewed as a step backward for the criminal justice system. The principle of sentence progression, which allows for gradual transitions to less restrictive regimes based on merit and behavior, is a cornerstone of rehabilitative justice and a right guaranteed under existing law, aiming to reintegrate offenders into society.
Conversely, proponents of the PEC’s stricter measures argue that the egregious nature of crimes like feminicide and pedophilia, alongside the societal threat posed by gang leaders, warrants an exception to standard penal practices. They contend that full sentence completion for such offenses would send a strong message of zero tolerance and enhance public safety by ensuring these offenders are incarcerated for the maximum duration, prioritizing punishment and deterrence over rehabilitation in these specific, severe cases.






