Moraes supports convictions for Marielle and Anderson murders, citing political motives and militia ties
A Supreme Court Justice has cast a pivotal vote, recommending convictions for five individuals accused of orchestrating the 2018 assassinations of Rio de Janeiro councilwoman Marielle Franco and her driver, Anderson Gomes. This decision marks a significant advancement in one of Brazil’s most politically charged and enduring criminal cases.
The vote, delivered on Wednesday by Justice Alexandre de Moraes, the rapporteur of the criminal action within the Federal Supreme Court’s First Panel, sets a critical precedent as the trial moves forward. It highlights the complex interplay of political power, alleged corruption, and organized crime at the heart of the investigation.
Among those targeted by the recommendation are prominent figures including Domingos Brazão, a Rio de Janeiro State Court of Accounts counselor; his brother, former federal deputy João Francisco Brazão; former Rio Civil Police chief Rivaldo Barbosa; ex-military police officer Ronald Paulo de Alves, known as Major Ronald; and former aide Robson Calixto Fonseca, or “Peixe.”
Justice Moraes’s detailed analysis delineated specific charges for each defendant, ranging from triple-qualified homicide to obstruction of justice, underscoring the layered nature of the alleged conspiracy that shook the nation.
Key Figures Face Varied Legal Outcomes
Moraes’s vote specifically calls for the conviction of the Brazão brothers—Domingos and Chiquinho—on charges of double triple-qualified homicide, attempted homicide against Marielle’s press advisor Fernanda Chaves, and criminal organization. This robust accusation aligns with the prosecution’s view of them as the primary instigators behind the brutal killings, driven by a desire to maintain their illicit power structures in Rio.
Major Ronald, identified as the individual responsible for monitoring Marielle Franco’s daily routine and relaying critical information to the actual perpetrators, is recommended for conviction on the same double triple-qualified homicide and attempted homicide charges. Robson Calixto, however, faces a narrower recommendation, limited to criminal organization for his alleged ties to the Brazãos’ land-grabbing and militia activities.
Deep Roots of a Political Assassination Plot
The Supreme Court Justice emphatically stated that the assassinations of Marielle Franco and Anderson Gomes were fundamentally politically motivated, stemming from vested interests in maintaining irregular land occupation schemes in Rio de Janeiro. He characterized Marielle as a formidable “stone in the path” for the Brazão brothers’ criminal enterprise, whose parliamentary actions directly challenged their illicit activities and power base. Moraes underscored that the execution served a dual purpose: to eliminate a vocal opponent who threatened their control and to send a chilling message to other potential adversaries, highlighting the profound symbolic weight of the crime within a volatile political landscape.
Corroborating Evidence Fortifies Lessa’s Testimony
A central point of contention for the defense teams throughout the trial has been the credibility and weight of Ronnie Lessa’s plea bargain agreement. Lawyers for the accused have consistently argued that the case relies solely on Lessa’s testimony, asserting a lack of independent corroborating evidence to support his claims.
Justice Moraes, however, firmly rejected these assertions during his vote. He emphasized that Lessa’s collaboration was not an isolated piece of evidence but was “corroborated by diverse proofs produced by the police” and validated extensively during the penal instruction phase under the constitutional right to adversarial proceedings.
These corroborating elements, as cited by the rapporteur, encompass a wide array of evidence, including official documents, multiple witness depositions, rigorous technical analyses, recovered digital communications, and extensive data gleaned from related investigations. Together, these pieces of evidence significantly strengthen the prosecution’s narrative and diminish claims of a solely testimonial basis.
Militia Ties and Underestimated Repercussions
Further bolstering the prosecution’s case, Justice Moraes pointed to what he described as “abundant evidence” linking the Brazão brothers directly to Rio’s notorious militias. He unequivocally stated, “They didn’t just have contact with the militia, they *were* the militia,” illustrating the depth of their alleged involvement and their integral role within these criminal organizations.
The minister also revealed that Marielle Franco was not the initial target considered for elimination. Investigations suggested that State Representative Marcelo Freixo, also from the PSOL party, was initially discussed as a target. However, this option was reportedly discarded due to his robust security detail, which would have significantly complicated the execution, according to delator Ronnie Lessa.
Moraes argued that the ultimate choice of Marielle was a confluence of political factors and deeply ingrained prejudices, including misogyny, racism, and discrimination. He highlighted her identity as “a black and poor woman” who courageously dared to confront the powerful interests of militiamen in the Zona Oeste of Rio.
The perpetrators, according to Moraes, likely misjudged the potential fallout, believing Marielle’s assassination would generate less public outcry and repercussions. Ronnie Lessa’s own plea corroborates this, mentioning the subsequent surprise among the mandantes regarding the massive national and international dimension the case ultimately garnered, a scale they evidently did not anticipate.
Rivaldo Barbosa’s Role: Obstruction, Not Homicide
Significantly, Justice Moraes’s vote distinguishes the charges against former Civil Police Chief Rivaldo Barbosa. While he acknowledges no sufficient proof of Barbosa’s direct involvement in planning the homicides, the evidence strongly indicates his role in a post-crime cover-up, actively working to impede justice.
Consequently, Moraes advocated for a “legal adjustment” of the Public Prosecutor’s Office’s accusation, rejecting the homicide charge but voting to condemn Barbosa for obstruction of justice and passive corruption. The Justice condemned his actions as “a shameful episode for the police,” referring to the former director of homicides then acting to protect criminals.
The Judiciary’s Next Steps
With Justice Moraes’s comprehensive vote now registered, the First Panel of the Supreme Court anticipates the manifestos of Ministers Cristiano Zanin, Cármen Lúcia, and Flávio Dino. These subsequent votes will culminate in a majority decision that determines the final verdict for the accused.
Should the majority align with the rapporteur’s condemnation, the collegiate body will proceed to fix the specific penalties for each convicted individual, marking a critical phase in the protracted legal battle surrounding these high-profile assassinations.
Reflecting on a Landmark Decision
Justice Moraes’s vote represents a pivotal moment in the ongoing pursuit of justice for Marielle Franco and Anderson Gomes, underscoring the judiciary’s commitment to addressing complex cases involving political violence and organized crime at the highest levels.






