Federal jury orders Carnival to pay $300,000 to passenger who fell after 14 shots of tequila

Diana Sanders, 45-year-old nurse from Vacaville, in Califórnia, won in Justiça a case against Carnival Cruise Line. A federal jury in Miami ruled that the company must pay her $300,000. The incident occurred in January 2024, during a trip on the ship Carnival Radiance. Sanders claimed that the crew served around 14 shots of tequila in just over eight hours, even with visible signs of intoxication.
Ela fell down a staircase and woke up in the crew restricted area. Injuries include concussion, persistent headaches, possible traumatic brain injury, back problems, tailbone problems and bruises. The verdict came last Friday after a week of trial. The jury awarded 60% liability to Carnival for failing to exercise reasonable care. Sanders was considered 40% negligent due to its own consumption.
Queda happened after a sequence of doses in the ship’s bar
Sanders was aboard Carnival Radiance on January 5, 2024. According to the lawsuit, the crew served the doses between approximately 2:58 pm and 11:37 pm. The average interval was around 37 minutes per dose. Pouco after leaving a casino bar, she fell between 11:45 pm and 12:20 am the following day.
The passenger said she blacked out and woke up on the floor of a crew-only staircase. Ela reported receiving conflicting information from the team and felt treated as a suspect. Sanders recorded a video on social media, posted by the lawyer, in which he describes his concern about the lack of explanations about what happened. The company did not provide complete images from security cameras. Parte from the critical period video, about 30 minutes long, was missing.
Responsabilidade divided and moral damages in the focus of the trial
The case was processed in the federal Justiça of Flórida. Sanders’s defense argued that Carnival has a duty to supervise at-risk passengers. The company operates with unlimited drink packages that encourage consumption, according to lawyers. Eles highlighted that employees receive tips and may prioritize sales over safety.
The jury recognized that Sanders was also responsible. Ainda thus found Carnival largely at fault for continuing to serve alcohol. The $300,000 compensation covers emotional pain, suffering and mental anguish. The amount requested initially was 250 thousand dollars, but the jury increased the amount. Sanders works as a nurse at Vacaville’s hospital and did not give an in-person interview about the case.
- The crew poured approximately 14 shots of tequila in eight hours and 39 minutes
- Sanders was found unconscious in a crew-only area
- Security Vídeo failed for about 30 minutes in the registry
- Júri attributed 60% of the blame to Carnival and 40% to the passenger
- Final Indenização exceeded the amount requested by the defense
Advogados and expert comment on duty of care on ships
Lawyer Spencer Aronfeld, who represents Sanders, stated that the case reveals risks of all-inclusive packages. Ele said the model pressures crew to serve more to increase tips. Outro consulted a lawyer, unconnected with the case, reinforced that cruise companies are responsible for the safety of passengers even in international waters. Jurisdiction applies to the place of departure or headquarters of the company.
Sanders mentioned that the process goes beyond individual consumption. Para she, these are systemic security failures on board. Carnival contested the verdict. In a statement, the company informed that it disagrees with the decision and will seek a new trial and appeal. Representantes did not detail the arguments for the appeal.
Detalhes ship and beverage package
The Carnival Radiance is a ship in the Carnival Corporation fleet. The incident occurred on a trip that included a drinks package. Sanders purchased the package, which allowed unlimited consumption at various points on the ship. The legal action pointed out that the arrangement of bars in different locations facilitates constant access to alcohol.
Especialistas in maritime law observe that cases like this rarely come to trial. Most are usually resolved out of court. Este process lasted around 18 months since filing in 2024.
Próximos steps include feature of Carnival
The decision is not yet final. Carnival plans to appeal and request a new trial. Enquanto that, Sanders awaits payment of the compensation determined by the jury. The case reignites debate about the responsibility of cruise operators in controlling alcohol consumption.
Passageiros with unlimited packages face pressure to take advantage of the investment, according to recurring reports in similar processes. Carnival did not comment on specific details of the incident beyond the feature note.






