Angelina Jolie wins lawsuit over vineyard and does not need to hand over emails to Pitt

Actress Angelina Jolie scored an important victory in Tribunal Superior of Condado of Los Angeles. Judge Cindy Pánuco ruled that she does not need to disclose 22 emails exchanged with her legal team and businesspeople regarding the sale of her shareholding in French winery Chateau Miraval. The decision, announced Monday (May 4), revokes a previous order from December that had required the delivery of correspondence.
The measure marks a new chapter in the dispute that has been going on for years between Jolie and Brad Pitt over ownership of the project. The former couple purchased the winery in 2008 for US$28.4 million, a value that corresponds to approximately R$157.15 million at the current price. Durante divorce proceedings in 2016, Jolie sold his share to the Russian group Stoli without prior consent from Pitt.
Brad Pitt demands millions in compensation
The actor disputes the sale carried out unilaterally by his ex-wife. Pitt filed a lawsuit asking for US$35 million, the equivalent of R$187 million, in compensation for the financial damages he claims to have suffered from the transaction. Segundo he, the sale significantly damaged the value of his stake in the vineyard and impacted businesses related to the venture.
Pitt’s argument centers on the allegation that Jolie sold his stake without consulting him in advance, allegedly violating prior agreements between the two. Documentos legal documents show that the actor had been asking for the disclosure of his ex’s emails to support his defense. Judge Pánuco, however, understood that correspondence is protected by the right of communication between client and lawyer, a fundamental principle of professional secrecy.
Histórico of Hollywood couple tensions
Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt made their relationship public in 2006 after meeting on the set of the movie “Mr. & Sra. Smith.” The two formalized their union in marriage in 2014. Menos two years later, in 2016, Jolie filed for divorce, citing irreconcilable differences, leaving the relationship on hold for eight years. The divorce was signed only at the end of 2024.
Apesar of the formal separation, financial and property issues between the ex-spouses remain under litigation. The French vineyard became a central symbol of this judicial war. Além of the dispute over Chateau Miraval, both continue to be involved in other legal actions related to common property acquired during the marriage:
- Custódia shared minor children and parental rights
- Divisão of jointly acquired real estate
- Propriedade intellectual and rights to joint projects
- Compensação financial for mutual investments
Decisão judicial reinforces professional secrecy
Judge Cindy Pánuco based her sentence on the legal principle of privileged communication, which guarantees confidentiality between the client and the legally representing professional. The protection applies specifically to the 22 emails exchanged between Jolie, his law firm and commercial representatives during the shareholding sale negotiations.
Para Jolie, the decision represents significant relief, preventing potentially sensitive correspondence from being accessed by the Pitt defense. Para the actor, the determination eliminates an evidentiary tool that could demonstrate misconduct in the transaction. Especialistas in family law consulted by international publications such as Daily Mail and TMZ point out that the result reflects the strict interpretation of American courts regarding the attorney-client privilege, even in contexts of contested divorce.
The ruling does not end the dispute between the ex-spouses over Chateau Miraval. Outras issues remain pending adjudication, including assessment of Pitt’s alleged harm and possible appeal of the decision. The processes should continue to be processed in the coming months in Los Angeles.







