Textor and Montenegro exchange attacks and former president mentions SAF 171 in Botafogo

The atmosphere of rivalry behind the scenes at Botafogo reached a new level of tension this Monday. John Textor, owner of SAF alvinegra, and former president Carlos Augusto Montenegro exchanged serious accusations and public ironies. The American countered recent criticism and challenged the former director to invest in Estados Unidos. The dispute involves the legacy of the 2024 titles and the club’s financial control.
The crisis took on the form of a personal war after months of distance between the parties. Textor accuses Montenegro of leading a behind-the-scenes smear campaign. On the other hand, the former president questions the financial health of the current management and the association’s debt. The split occurs shortly after the club reached the top of South American football.

Textor challenges former manager to win NFL titles
The American businessman reacted sarcastically to the statements made by Montenegro, who called him a coward in recent interviews. John Textor used an example from his homeland to confront his former ally. Ele suggested that the Brazilian buy Dallas Cowboys, one of the biggest franchises in the American Football League (NFL). The objective would be to prove that Montenegro can beat Super Bowl outside of its usual environment.
Textor highlighted that he changed countries and learned a new culture to manage Alvinegro. Ele stated that he was never cowardly in his business or sporting decisions. The SAF owner recalled that he invited Montenegro to the Ballon D’Or ceremony in Paris, but the Brazilian did not attend. Para the American, the former president has been working against his leadership since the first months after the achievements of 2024.
- Troca of barbs started after audio leaks criticizing SAF
- Textor claims Montenegro tries to erase management’s recent success
- Ex-president missed official club award events in 2025
- Americano denies prioritizing Lyon over Botafogo
- Relacionamento between social club and company is at a critical point
Montenegro cites SAF 171 and criticizes debt increase
Carlos Augusto Montenegro’s response was immediate and full of technical and legal terms. The former director mocked the proposal for a “2.0 version” of the SAF presented by John Textor. According to Montenegro, the project is nothing more than a strategy to increase the social club’s debts. Ele used the number 171, a reference to the crime of embezzlement, to define the American’s plan.
The former president detailed that the proposal to increase the social share in SAF from 10% to 20% is a financial trap. Ele explained that this would increase the responsibility for the debt, which currently amounts to R$2.7 billion. Montenegro assured that no one in the association is interested in assuming such a liability. Para he, the management of Textor is leaving a trail of legal and financial uncertainty for the future.
The accusation of arrogance also guided the former president’s speech. Ele stated that Textor uses communication channels immorally to attack those who disagree with his ideas. Montenegro denied manipulating the press or influencers against the investor. The former leader defined himself simply as a fan who is concerned about the direction of the institution. Ele recalled that, in the past, he celebrated the American as a hero, but that the scenario changed.
Disputa judicial and blockades complicate political scenario
The clash between the two leaders occurs at a time of uncertainty in the courts. Justiça once again suspended the political rights of Eagle Bidco, Textor’s holding company, within the club. Essa’s decision reaffirms Durcesio Mello’s power on the associative side and weakens the American’s direct influence on certain decisions. The fight with Montenegro is seen as a reflection of this political instability.
Textor claims that he “shined the former president’s shoes” in the past to try to include him in the project. Ele says he is offended by the way the criticisms emerged shortly after the first challenges of 2025. The investor maintains the statement that Botafogo is his favorite club in the multi-club group. However, pressure for results and transparency in accounts remain Montenegro’s main weapons.
Abaixo, the central points of the management conflict:
- Valor of the debt cited by Montenegro currently reaches R$2.7 billion
- SAF 2.0’s Proposta would increase shareholding to 20% of shares
- Direitos politicians from Eagle Bidco remain suspended by recent court decision
- Textor claims Montenegro has been sending derogatory messages to journalists for months
The scenario for the coming weeks is one of intense monitoring by the fans. Enquanto the team seeks to maintain competitiveness on the field, the board needs to deal with the deterioration of its image. The public war between the owner of SAF and the biggest name in the club’s recent political history is unlikely to let up. The impact of this crisis on the search for new investors or sponsorship is still uncertain on Rio and Janeiro.






