Elderly man sentenced to 50 years after DNA from chewing gum links him to two cold case murders
A 74-year-old Washington man received a sentence of 50 years to life in prison after pleading guilty to two murders that remained unsolved for decades. Mitchell Gaff admitted to killing 21-year-old Susan Vesey in 1980 and 42-year-old Judith “Judy” Weaver in 1984, both in Everett. The breakthrough in the investigation came through an unconventional method: detectives posed as gum industry researchers and collected Gaff’s DNA from a chewing gum sample he provided during what he believed was a product testing session.
The sentencing hearing last week marked the conclusion of a case that haunted multiple families for more than four decades. Investigators with the Everett Police Department employed the creative undercover strategy after traditional methods failed to identify the perpetrator. The DNA sample obtained from the gum was processed through CODIS, the federal criminal database, which ultimately connected Gaff to Weaver’s 1984 murder scene.
Undercover operation leads to May 2024 arrest
Detectives visited Gaff’s residence while disguised as market researchers conducting studies for the chewing gum industry. They offered him free samples to try, which he accepted without suspicion. The suspect provided the undercover officers with a chewed piece of gum that became the key piece of evidence linking him to crimes committed decades earlier. Gaff was arrested in May 2024 following the DNA match confirmation.
While in custody, investigators connected him to a second murder. Susan Vesey had been killed inside her apartment on July 13, 1980, just one day after celebrating her 21st birthday. The young mother was murdered while her three-month-old son, Joshua Vesey, was present in the home. Authorities charged Gaff with both homicides, bringing long-awaited answers to families who had spent years searching for justice.
Survivor confronts attacker after 47 years
The courtroom proceedings included powerful testimony from Jacqueline O’Brien, a former law enforcement officer who survived a violent assault by Gaff in 1979. The attack occurred in the garage of her Everett home, and O’Brien described fearing for her life during the encounter. She managed to escape and later played a crucial role in helping authorities identify her attacker. O’Brien’s survival and cooperation with investigators proved essential to the case.
Addressing the court during the sentencing hearing, O’Brien stated that her nightmare occurred 47 years ago but remained vivid in her memory. Her testimony provided context for Gaff’s pattern of violence against women that spanned multiple years. Following the 1979 attack on O’Brien, Gaff was arrested several times and served prison time for raping two teenage sisters in 1984, demonstrating a consistent history of sexual violence.
Victims’ families deliver emotional impact statements
Joshua Vesey, Susan’s son who was only three months old when his mother was murdered, confronted Gaff directly in court. He explained how the defendant had stolen more than just a life from him and his sister. The loss meant they would never experience their mother’s unconditional love, care, or guidance as they grew up. Joshua emphasized that Gaff could have ended the confusion, suspicion, and pain that spread through his family at any point over the decades.
Leon Gregory, Judith Weaver’s brother, shared the prolonged suffering his family endured during the 42 years without answers. He noted that his parents, one brother, and two sisters all passed away without ever knowing who killed Judy. The decades of uncertainty compounded the grief, as family members grappled with the possibility that they might never receive closure or see justice served.
- Susan Vesey was murdered on July 13, 1980, one day after her 21st birthday
- Judith Weaver was killed in 1984 at age 42
- Jacqueline O’Brien survived an attack in 1979 and helped identify Gaff
- Gaff served previous prison time for raping two teenage sisters in 1984
- DNA evidence from chewing gum led to his arrest in May 2024
Defendant apologizes but blames substance abuse
During the sentencing hearing, Gaff offered an apology to the families present in the courtroom. He claimed his remorse stemmed not from being caught, but from the consequences his actions had caused. The defendant acknowledged that none of his victims did anything to deserve him entering their lives. However, Gaff attributed his history of violence to drugs and alcohol, pointing to substance abuse as a contributing factor to his crimes.
The judge rejected the defense team’s request for a minimum sentence, citing Gaff’s extensive history of sexually motivated and extremely violent crimes against women. The court noted his attempts to cover up the murders throughout the years as an aggravating factor. In determining the appropriate punishment, the judge stated that the minimum sentence should reflect the number of years the families had to wait for justice, ultimately imposing 50 years to life in prison.
DNA technology brings justice after four decades
The case demonstrates how advances in forensic technology and creative investigative techniques can solve crimes that remained cold for decades. The use of CODIS, the Combined DNA Index System maintained by the FBI, allowed investigators to match the DNA profile from the chewing gum sample to evidence collected at the 1984 crime scene. This breakthrough came after traditional investigative methods had failed to identify a suspect for more than 40 years.
The Everett Police Department’s unconventional approach of posing as gum industry researchers represents the type of innovative thinking required to crack long-dormant cases. By creating a non-threatening scenario that encouraged Gaff to voluntarily provide a DNA sample, detectives obtained evidence that would have been difficult to acquire through conventional means. The successful prosecution brings closure to two families and removes a violent offender from society for the remainder of his life.






