Metacritic reveals ranking of the 10 best Mario games with scores up to 97 points

Super Mario Galaxy leads the ranking of the best-rated titles in the mustachioed plumber franchise, according to data from Metacritic. Três games reach the maximum score of 97 points: Galaxy itself, its sequel Galaxy 2 and Super Mario Odyssey. The list brings together classics that marked entire generations of players on different Nintendo consoles, from the Nintendo 64 to the Switch.
Metacritic uses an algorithm that aggregates analyzes from large specialized media outlets, generating a weighted average. Alguns sites are given greater weight in this equation, resulting in a final score for each game. Quando and Metascore are identical, the tiebreaker criteria considers the number of analyses. Confira the complete list with 10 titles that defined the history of the series.
Super Mario Galaxy and the revolution with 97 points
Super Mario Galaxy achieved the position of the highest rated game in the franchise when it debuted in 2007 on Nintendo Wii. The innovation was in the use of the console’s motion sensor, a feature that opened up creative possibilities for gameplay. Mario travels to small planets where he explores unique power-ups such as Bee Mario, which allows him to fly, and Boo Mario, which allows him to walk through walls.
The objective remained familiar: collect Power Stars and rescue Princesa Peach from Bowser’s clutches. Cada planet hid surprises that took advantage of space physics and explored the three-dimensional environment in an innovative way. Atualmente, the game is available on Nintendo Switch for R$389.90 as part of a collection that includes the sequel.
Super Mario Galaxy 2 arrived three years later, in 2010, also for Wii and maintained a rating of 97. The sequel brought significant improvements, including the return of Yoshi as a mount. Novos power-ups were added, and the game included a remastered version of Whomp’s famous Fortress stage, taken from Super Mario 64. Galaxy 2 is considered a balanced evolution of the original concept, preserving everything that worked while expanding the repertoire of ideas.
Super Mario Odyssey with 97 and revolutionary mechanics
Super Mario Odyssey (97 points) takes direct inspiration from Mario 64, allowing exploration of open 3D environments. The big new feature is Cappy, a magical hat that Mario can use to possess enemies and objects, gaining their special abilities. Essa mechanics radically transforms the way you solve challenges and explore stages.
The player travels through several uniquely themed kingdoms on a mission to save Princesa Peach, once again kidnapped by Bowser. A group of rabbits called Broodals serve as minor villains throughout the adventure. Avaliadores highlight how the game modernizes the series, featuring a creative level of design that keeps each area fresh. The title costs R$299 on the Nintendo eShop of Switch.

Clássicos of the old consoles in the list
Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 (94 points) is essentially a remake of Super Mario Bros. 3 original for the NES, released in 2003 for Game Boy Advance. The plumber brothers once again face the mission of saving Princesa Peach in a journey full of challenging platforms. The Nintendo e-Reader peripheral added extra content via paper cards with encoded data.
The full version with all 38 phases is available on Nintendo Switch and Switch 2 via Nintendo Switch Online. Super Mario 64 (94 points) revolutionized the franchise by laying the foundations of the 3D platformer genre. Lançado originally in Nintendo 64, the game features 120 Estrelas of Poder to collect across unique scenarios filled with allies and villains.
The creative level design explored technical innovations of the time, including the analogue stick and the controversial Z button. Diversos players point out the Z button as questionable by today’s standards, but recognize the historical importance. Atualmente, is available via Nintendo Switch Online + Pacote Adicional on both current consoles.
Títulos with 93 points and different playing styles
Super Mario 3D World (93 points) mixes 3D platforming with the chaos of classic 2D adventures. Lançado in 2013 for Nintendo Wii U and inspired by Super Mario 3D Land from 3DS, allows up to four simultaneous players in cooperative mode. Cada one chooses between Mario, Luigi, Peach and Toad, characters with unique abilities to jump and attack.
The goal is to save Reino from Anamigas, an archipelago of eight different worlds. The Switch version includes the new expansion called Bowser’s Fury and costs R$299 on the Nintendo eShop. Mario Kart: Super Circuit (93 points) was the first portable title in the racing series, released in 2001 for Game Boy Advance. Intelligent Systems adopted more complex gameplay with realistic physics and graphics that simulate 3D.
The game was a pioneer in revisiting old tracks from Super Mario Kart and Super Nintendo, making all routes available to unlock. Multiplayer used Cabo Link for up to 4 players on a single cartridge. Atualmente, is playable on Switch and Switch 2 via Nintendo Switch Online + Pacote Adicional.
Paper Mario and the 93-point paper RPG
Paper Mario (93 points) innovates by mixing platform with RPG elements since its launch in 2001 for Nintendo 64. Personagens takes the form of paper inserted into three-dimensional scenarios, creating a striking visual aesthetic. Mario journeys through Reino Cogumelo to free the Espíritos Estelares imprisoned by Bowser.
Battles are turn-based, but require real-time action commands to maximize damage. The partner system allows Mario to join forces with unlikely allies like Goombas and Koopas who would normally be enemies. The narrative brings humor and creativity in the selection of these characters. Está available on Switch and Switch 2 via Nintendo Switch Online + Pacote Adicional.
The final titles with 92 points
Super Mario Bros. Wonder (92 points) returned to the pure 2D platformer style in 2023, but with creative level design that makes each level unique and memorable. Mario and friends are invited by Príncipe Florian to visit Flor’s Reino, but they must stop Bowser from taking over the world after stealing the powerful Flor Fenomenal.
Cooperative multiplayer supports up to 12 people, offering chaotic fun. The game costs R$329.90 on Switch and R$439.90 on Switch 2 with expansion pack included. Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 (92 points) is a remake of the SNES classic, featuring all the original levels. Mario and Luigi discover that Peach was kidnapped by Bowser from Dinossauros’s Terra.
Esta version does not offer co-op mode, but allows you to choose between Mario (faster) or Luigi (jumps higher). Special Power-ups grant additional abilities. Publicado originally in 2001, is available for Switch and Switch 2 through Nintendo Switch Online + Pacote Adicional.
Resumo of the top 10 according to Metacritic
- Super Mario Galaxy — 97 points
- Super Mario Galaxy 2 — 97 points
- Super Mario Odyssey — 97 points
- Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 — 94 points
- Super Mario 64 — 94 points
- Super Mario 3D World — 93 points
- Mario Kart: Super Circuit — 93 points
- Paper Mario — 93 points
- Super Mario Bros. Wonder — 92 points
- Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 — 92 points






