Agency reveals Tesla used data that distorts safety to approve autonomous cars in Europe

In an effort to secure the permission of its fully autonomous driving system, known as “Full Self-Driving” (FSD), in Europe, Tesla provided regulatory bodies in Sweden and the Netherlands with safety information that, as researchers point out, could characterize a marketing practice with misleading information.
The data presented was developed internally by the company itself. A Reuters investigation, published the previous month, revealed that Tesla CEO Elon Musk and other executives have, over the last year, made increasingly frequent references to statistics that suggest that FSD would be up to ten times safer than human driving.
However, Reuters news agency identified a series of inconsistent comparisons in the data underlying these numbers, which would have inflated Tesla’s claims about the safety of its technology.
The automaker has forwarded potentially exaggerated safety information to some European regulators, according to correspondence obtained by Reuters through requests for access to public documents.

The company is seeking wider acceptance of its FSD system in a region where it is struggling to reverse the loss of automotive market share.
To begin the approval process, Tesla contacted RDW, which is the traffic regulatory authority for the Netherlands, in late 2024.
In a communication sent to RDW in November 2024, Tesla included a link to its safety report and stated that the “intensified use” of FSD “contributes to making roads safer.”
The company charges a monthly fee for access to the system, which allows the vehicle to operate autonomously in certain conditions but still requires the driver to maintain attention.
After a period of more than twelve months of testing and discussions with Tesla, RDW granted approval for the use of FSD in the Netherlands in April. Currently, the regulatory body is working to obtain authorization for the system throughout the European Union on behalf of the automaker.
RDW declined to comment on the concerns raised by Reuters regarding safety statistics released by Tesla.
In a statement, the Dutch agency stated that it “does not rely on marketing claims or external statistics” to make its decisions, stating that it carries out its own “tests, analyzes and verifications” of the system both on public roads and on controlled tracks. RDW did not specify whether it evaluated Tesla’s safety statistics for the United States.
RDW further added that Tesla “collected a large volume of data” during the testing phase and that the agency “validated, tested and audited this information.” However, the agency did not provide details about the type of data collected or the metrics used.
Tesla, in turn, did not respond to requests for comment on the matter.
Questions about the projections of 32 thousand lives saved
Shortly after the decision was released on April 10, Ivan Komusanac, policy manager at Tesla, sent an email to Swedish regulators requesting similar approval for FSD in his country.
Attached was a slideshow that claimed Tesla vehicles equipped with the system could travel seven times longer between accidents than the average human driver in the United States.
The presentation also assured that FSD technology would have the potential to save 32,000 lives and prevent 1.9 million injuries.
Researchers interviewed by Reuters called these numbers highly misleading because they are based on the unrealistic premise that all vehicles in the United States — including cargo trucks and motorcycles, which have a higher incidence of accidents — would be replaced by Tesla cars equipped with the FSD system.
The estimate still assumes that each Tesla vehicle is, in fact, at least seven times safer than the model it would be replacing in the fleet.
The Reuters investigation also highlighted that Tesla tends to overestimate the safety of its technology when comparing the accident rate in vehicles with FSD that activated airbags with the general accident rate in the United States, which covers less serious incidents.






