Bahia Court of Justice upholds conviction of man who amputated his foot for R$1.5 million fraud

A public servant’s attempt to reverse his conviction for defrauding insurance after amputating his own foot was blocked. Judge José Alfredo Cerqueira da Silva, from the 2nd Vice-Presidency of the Court of Justice of Bahia (TJ/BA), did not accept the special appeal filed by the defense.
The order, issued last year, prevented the request from reaching the Superior Court of Justice (STJ), justifying that the second instance decision was still subject to infringing embargoes.
With the confirmation of the sentence, the public servant began serving his sentence in an open regime in May, with the application of measures restricting his rights, which brought the details of the case to the public.
Purchasing Policies Preceded the Accident
According to the complaint, the man, aged 26 at the time, signed four insurance contracts with the companies Allianz, Zurich, Tokio Marine and Sompo between the months of June and July 2019. The total value of the compensation provided for in the policies amounted to R$1.5 million.
Approximately six weeks after taking out these insurance policies, his right foot was amputated. He then requested compensation from insurance companies, claiming to have been the victim of a kidnapping, assault and mutilation by unidentified individuals.
His lawyers’ arguments revolved around the absence of evidence to prove the planning of self-harm for profit, therefore requiring acquittal.
Forensic Analysis and Testimony Disproved the Defendant’s Account
In the victorious opinion during the trial, judge Julio Cezar Lemos Travessa concluded that the guilt and evidence of the crime were established through expert reports, insurance company records, medical records, insurance contracts and the set of testimonies obtained in the investigation and during the process.
The reporting judge emphasized the conclusion of four insurance contracts in a very short period of time, followed by the amputation of the limb just six weeks after the accessions. He also noted how quickly compensation claims were filed, days after the incident.
According to the judge, the server’s narrative presented significant inconsistencies. Despite declaring that he had no enemies, he claimed to have been kidnapped by strangers who mutilated him without any apparent explanation. Furthermore, he was unable to detail who the alleged attackers were, what tool they used or how the crime occurred.
A fundamental aspect for the decision was the finding of the employee’s backpack, containing several belongings, close to the amputation site, which directly contradicted the version of a robbery.
The quote from the judge’s opinion highlighted: “It is implausible that a public servant, with modest remuneration, working as an administrative assistant at a Federal University, takes out four life and personal accident policies in a brief period, evidencing an unusual concern and allocating a considerable portion of his monthly income to cover the costs of these multiple insurance companies.”
Faced with such arguments, the majority of members of the judging panel accepted the opinion of judge Julio Cezar Lemos Travessa, ratifying the conviction for fraud.
Later, the defense filed a special appeal with the intention of taking the case to the STJ. However, judge José Alfredo Cerqueira da Silva, from the 2nd vice-presidency of the TJ/BA, denied admission. The judge clarified that the second degree decision was handed down by a majority and that infringing embargoes were still applicable, thus preventing direct access to the higher court, in accordance with Precedent 207 of the STJ.
Thus, the sentence imposed on the public official remained unchanged.
The court case number 0000568-08.2019.8.05.0237 contains the ruling of the second instance and the decision of the vice-president of the TJ/BA, detailing the entire procedure and legal grounds.






