Court settlement allows Florida couple to raise girl born from swapped embryo

A couple who had a daughter through in vitro fertilization, and who later discovered that the embryo used was not genetically theirs, reached a legal consensus with the child’s biological parents. The decision allows permanent custody of the girl to be maintained by the family that gave birth to her.
At an early stage, in April, Tiffany Score and Steven Mills expressed, in the legal case they brought against the Fertility Center, in Orlando, Florida (USA), that they had developed an “intensely strong emotional bond” with little Shea throughout the pregnancy. Although they wished to remain with the girl, they recognized that the child “should be legally and morally reintegrated with her biological parents, as long as they had the conditions, capacity and desire to adopt her”.
In April 2025, Ms. Score was implanted with what she believed to be one of her own embryos. However, on December 11, 2025, after the birth of Shea Score Mills, the couple’s first daughter, both Caucasians, they noticed that the baby did not have features similar to either of them.
In January, Tiffany and Steven began legal action against the Fertility Center and its director of reproductive endocrinology, Milton McNichol. The complaint alleged that another patient’s embryo was implanted in Tiffany’s uterus in April 2025. This procedural failure led to the birth of Shea, who is currently six months old and is not genetically related to the couple, as detailed in the lawsuit.
“This outcome represents the end of a painful period in our trajectory, but, at the same time, it raises new questions that still require solutions,” the couple said in a statement. “Additionally, the future of our own embryos remains uncertain, and the chances of obtaining answers are becoming increasingly slim,” they added, when the results of the DNA test were released.

Currently, according to court documents obtained by People magazine, the Florida-based couple has finalized a “consensually drafted custody agreement” with Shea’s genetic parents. The identities of these parents will remain “confidential,” according to the new legal record.
Although the specific terms of the agreement, signed last Monday (June 15), were not disclosed, the court document states that Tiffany and Steven will maintain their parental rights, assuming permanent custody of Shea.
This agreement, however, does not resolve all outstanding issues. The couple expresses concern about the fate of their frozen embryos and the possibility of having a biological child living with another family. The couple’s egg and sperm collections resulted in one viable male and two female embryos, which were kept frozen and stored throughout the period.
“Their male embryo is possibly still somewhere. It has been reported that there is an embryo in storage, but there is no confirmation as to whether it actually belongs to the couple,” said Jack Scarola, an attorney representing Tiffany and Steven.
As soon as the incident came to light, the management of the Fertility Center declared that it was in collaboration with the authorities. The objective was “to help parents identify the cause of a mistake that resulted in the birth of a child with no genetic link to them.”
In April of this year, the Fertility Center in Orlando announced its closure, but announced the opening of a new clinic at the same address.






