PGR supports maintenance of Jair Bolsonaro’s house arrest and requests retention of seized pistol

The Attorney General’s Office (PGR) presented an opinion this Thursday (1st) in which it defends that former president Jair Bolsonaro remains under house arrest. The entity’s position is awaited with attention, as it directly influences the former head of the Executive’s sentence regime.
The Federal Public Ministry’s assessment is based on investigations by the Civil Police of the Federal District, which chose not to indict Bolsonaro in relation to the seizure of his weapon during a blitz. The incident occurred when an Army soldier, responsible for the former president’s security, was transporting the weapons.
In the document, the PGR considers that the Civil Police investigation was appropriate and that the former president did not commit a “serious offense” in what happened. Serious misconduct in criminal execution can lead to regime regression, directly impacting benefits such as house arrest. Therefore, the gun incident would not be, in the Prosecutor’s Office’s view, sufficient reason to revoke Bolsonaro’s current benefit.
Given the opinion, Jair Bolsonaro’s defense will have 48 hours to present its formal statement in the judicial process.
The final decision on the continuity or revocation of Bolsonaro’s domicile regime belongs to Minister Alexandre de Moraes, of the Federal Supreme Court (STF). He is the criminal execution rapporteur and should make his determination in the coming days, after analyzing the demonstrations.
Jair Bolsonaro has been in home custody since November of the previous year, serving a sentence of 27 years and three months in prison. The conviction is due to his role as leader of a conspiracy to try to annul the results of the 2022 elections and remain in power through a coup d’état.
The opinion, signed by Attorney General Paulo Gonet, states that the police authority’s conclusions, regarding Jair Bolsonaro, have “good support in the circumstances determined by the episode”.
The document also adds that
Supreme Court’s initial questioning
The previous week, Minister Alexandre de Moraes had already asked the PGR to comment within 48 hours on the existence of a “serious error” related to the seizure of the pistol.
Moraes made reference to an excerpt from the Criminal Executions Law, which establishes that “anyone sentenced to a custodial sentence who ‘improperly possesses an instrument capable of offending the physical integrity of another’ commits a serious offense.”
In his statement to the Civil Police, according to the document, Jair Bolsonaro confirmed that the seized firearm was his property and was at his residence while he was in prison. To the delegate, Bolsonaro would have justified his inauguration by saying that “he had three women at home” and that “he could not be unarmed”.
Previously, on June 25, the Attorney General of the Republic, Paulo Gonet, had asked the STF to wait for the Federal District Civil Police investigation to be completed.
According to Gonet, the process was still in the initial investigation phase and, “at this procedural moment, it does not indicate the concreteness of a situation characterizing disciplinary misconduct or non-compliance with the conditions of caution to which the convicted person is subject.”
Details of the military indictment
According to the corporation, Estácio Leite da Silva Filho carried the weapon without due authorization from its owner and in violation of the legal regulations required for such conduct.
Current jurisprudence indicates that functional possession does not grant permission to a public agent to carry a weapon registered in the name of third parties, characterizing the offense when the action is not in accordance with legal determinations.
Estácio Leite da Silva Filho was formally charged with illegal possession of a firearm, with the aggravating factor of being an Army sergeant. The military’s defense is being sought to comment on the case.
On the other hand, the Civil Police concluded that there was no crime committed by Jair Bolsonaro, since the former president has a valid registration for the Glock 9mm pistol.
The Civil Police declared that “Bolsonaro had a valid firearm registration, and there were no known restrictions for him to have the weapon regularly registered at his residence. It is a well-known fact that search and seizure warrants were executed at his residence and the firearm was not collected or even a restriction was placed on his registration. Therefore, I do not envisage the materiality and willful conduct of a possible crime of illegal possession of a restricted-use firearm.”






