The Athletic newspaper raises questions about who dominates the World Cups: Germany with 12 podiums or Brazil with 5 titles?

A debate about the real superiority between Germany and Brazil in World Cups was started by a North American sports magazine, The Athletic. The content, which expresses an opinion and is associated with the New York Times, was published last Monday, shortly after the elimination of the German team against Paraguay in a decisive phase of the global tournament.
The material, written by journalist Matt Slater, is titled “The Germans were once the kings of the World Cup, now they just aren’t that good.” The article argues that, before their below-expected performances at the most recent World Cups, Germany were considered the greatest team, boasting an impressive record of 12 appearances among the top three, including four trophies, four runners-up and four third-place finishes.

The publication highlights that Germany, by beating Argentina in 2014 and winning its fourth title in seventeen editions of the World Cup, established a remarkable sequence of four tournaments in a row, since 2002, always appearing among the three best. The final triumph came just five days after the historic 7-1 defeat against Brazil, host of that World Cup, a score that marked one of the biggest surprises in the entire history of the World Cups.
According to the analysis, at the time, only the most fervent Brazilian fans would question the idea that Germany was the greatest team in World Cup history. Although the Brazilian team holds the record of five world titles, the foreign article focuses the debate on the regularity of reaching the final stages. The German team, with its constant presence in the decisive phases, also accumulated four second and four third positions, added to its achievements.
When totaling these performances, Germany has been on the FIFA podium in 12 different moments, a number that exceeds any other country by three times. The main point raised is that the German team’s peaks were more significant than those of any other team, and even its lower performance phases proved to be of a higher level in comparison.
The article concludes by indicating that German football is going through a downturn, but recalls that a similar scenario occurred after the early elimination in the 1998 World Cup. During that period, the German federation implemented a profound restructuring in all its youth categories and training processes, a movement that was crucial for the national team’s resurgence as a global protagonist. The analysis suggests that a new cycle of recovery may be on the way, mirroring the capacity for renewal demonstrated in the past.






