New study reveals that running on the street is more demanding than on a treadmill, challenging the perception of many runners

Runners often encounter a peculiar feeling: the same distance and pace that seems easy on the treadmill can turn into a grueling challenge outdoors. This common perception has been the subject of scientific analysis, and new in-depth research offers clear answers about the physiological differences between the two running environments.
External variations influence effort during running
There are determining factors that contribute to the greater perceived and actual difficulty when running outside compared to the controlled environment of the treadmill.
Firstly, in outdoor running, the athlete needs to actively push themselves against the ground to advance. On the other hand, on the treadmill, the moving canvas offers a small assistance in propulsion, minimally relieving the body’s work.
Secondly, the resistance imposed by the air is a component absent in indoor running. Wind, even a light breeze, adds a counterforce that the body must overcome.
Studies indicate that, to more accurately simulate the effort of outdoor running, it is recommended to adjust the treadmill incline to 1%, which helps to replicate the extra difficulty generated by air resistance.
Finally, the irregularity of the terrain is a challenge unique to the external environment. Small inclines, unevenness and varied surfaces demand additional muscular effort that is not found on a flat treadmill.
Physiological analysis under controlled conditions
A vast body of research has been dedicated to comparing the physical demands of outdoor and treadmill running, seeking equivalence of conditions, such as the same speed.
A recent systematic review, which covered 34 studies on the topic, generally concluded that running on a treadmill is physiologically less demanding than running on solid ground. The findings revealed:
- Lower oxygen consumption — indicating less energy needed to maintain speed.
- Lower lactate accumulation — signaling a lower level of effort from the body to produce energy.
- Reduced heart rate — reflecting less intense work by the heart to pump blood and oxygen to the muscles.
Although these physiological measurements demonstrated that the treadmill was easier, the same research noted that participants, in general, considered running on the treadmill to be slightly more difficult in terms of perception.
This discrepancy can be partially attributed to the lack of natural air circulation indoors. Without the outside breeze, the body can overheat more quickly, which in turn can make exercise perceived as more strenuous.
Additionally, the boredom of staring at a wall while running on the treadmill can also influence perceived difficulty, making the experience more mentally challenging for some.
Comparative results for gaining physical conditioning
Considering the differences highlighted, it is plausible that outdoor training can offer a greater stimulus for improving physical conditioning than exclusive training on the treadmill. However, there is little research that directly addresses this issue with a focus on long-term results.
A study involving active young people demonstrated that six weeks of outdoor running resulted in slightly more significant improvements in physical fitness compared to an identical period of treadmill running, even though the sessions were of the same duration and intensity.
Similarly, another investigation of athletes revealed that six weeks of speed training performed outdoors provided a substantially greater increase in running speed compared to equivalent sessions on the treadmill.
Therefore, running two kilometers on the treadmill may be slightly less effective in increasing physical fitness than running the same distance outdoors. Even so, the treadmill continues to provide important benefits and is an excellent alternative when running outdoors is not viable or if, without it, training simply would not happen.
Psychological benefits and recovery from running injuries
Both types of running, on the treadmill and outdoors, have distinct advantages that align with different goals and needs of practitioners.
Research indicates that exercise done in contact with nature, outdoors, can generate notable psychological benefits. This includes reducing depression and significantly improving mood, in contrast to exercising indoors.
Consequently, for those who prioritize mental health as one of the main reasons for exercising, outdoor running may be the most advantageous option.
On the other hand, treadmills offer a stable and fully controllable training environment, which allows runners to precisely manage pace and distance. This feature makes the treadmill a superior option for individuals recovering from injuries, who need to control their training load accurately to avoid overdoing it.
The choice between treadmill and street depends on individual goals
When running outdoors, the body naturally needs to apply more force to propel itself, which translates into a more physically challenging workout. However, the treadmill should not be viewed as a shortcut or an inferior option.
If your main goal is to improve overall health and fitness, both outdoor running and treadmill running are effective. Instead of opting for one over the other, it is more productive to consider both modalities as complementary tools in the training program, using them according to the objectives, needs and conditions available at each moment.






