Itamaraty considers the US tariff of 12.5% on Brazilian products to be ‘arbitrary’ and points to a violation of the WTO

The Brazilian government, through the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mauro Vieira, formally contested the United States’ intention to implement an extra tariff of 12.5% on products originating in Brazil. The manifestation was forwarded to the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR).
This proposal marks the second time that the USTR has suggested a surcharge, based on Section 301 of the US Trade Law. The preliminary investigation suggests that Brazil, along with more than sixty other nations, did not act effectively to contain the sale of goods produced with labor similar to slavery.
The USTR, the body in charge of US trade policy, has the prerogative to investigate conduct that it considers harmful to US trade and may suggest the application of tariffs. In addition to the 12.5% surcharge, another 25% rate was also proposed for Brazilian goods, under the justification that Brazil takes actions that “encumber or restrict” commercial exchange.
In an official response, Itamaraty refuted the US assessment, classifying the investigation’s conclusions as “erroneous” and “arbitrary”. The ministry argues that the allegations lack support in the evidence and data presented by Brazil during the analysis of the case.
The Brazilian government document highlights that the American report ignored important details about the legislation and inspection measures that Brazil has actively applied to combat work in conditions similar to slavery.
The position expressed by the Brazilian government reiterated its long-standing view that unilateral actions, such as those based on Section 301 of US trade law, are fundamentally inconsistent with the principles of the global multilateral trading system.
“Topics addressed in this investigation, which include domestic legal regimes and inspection actions, should be resolved through collaboration and international dialogue, and not through trade sanctions”, states the text signed by Minister Vieira.
Tariff measure in disagreement with WTO rules
Itamaraty, in its official communication, highlighted that the imposition of a 12.5% tariff on Brazilian products by the USA goes against international trade standards.
For the Brazilian government, trade disputes of this nature should be addressed through the dispute resolution systems of the World Trade Organization (WTO), and not through unilateral tariff measures.
“When there are commercial disputes in the context of international agreements, Section 303 of the US Trade Act establishes the need to use formal dispute resolution instruments, such as those of the World Trade Organization, before taking unilateral actions”, details the document.
A crucial point raised by Itamaraty is the history of trade surplus between the United States and Brazil, which, since 2007, has exceeded the US$400 billion mark. This valuable information contextualizes the discussion, suggesting that such an imbalance in favor of the US contradicts and substantially weakens the grounds for applying the additional tariffs.






