São Paulo court acquits Thiago Brennand in rape case, but businessman remains in prison for other convictions

The São Paulo Court of Justice (TJSP) decided to reverse the conviction of businessman Thiago Brennand on one of the rape charges, resulting in his acquittal in this specific case. The decision was handed down by the 2nd Chamber of Criminal Law, which accepted the defense’s appeal, annulling the first instance sentence that predicted eight years in prison. Despite this outcome, Brennand remains in custody in the interior of São Paulo.
Currently, the businessman continues to serve closed sentences at Penitentiary II of Potim, located in the interior of São Paulo. These convictions are the result of other cases for crimes of rape and violence against women, whose sentences total more than two decades of imprisonment.
Details of the initial complaint that led to the lawsuit
The origin of the case analyzed by the TJSP goes back to a complaint formalized by the Public Ministry of São Paulo (MPSP) in December 2022. According to the accusation, the victim had felt unwell after drinking alcohol during a dinner, and was later taken by Brennand to a hotel room, where the alleged crime would have occurred.

The first conviction and the appeals presented
In August 2025, the 30th Criminal Court of the capital of São Paulo had sentenced the businessman to eight years in prison, in addition to determining compensation for moral damages in the amount of R$200,000. The defense, in turn, appealed the decision, claiming that the sexual relationship was consensual and pointing out weaknesses in the set of evidence presented. At the same time, the Public Ministry also filed an appeal, seeking Brennand’s conviction for other infractions related to the case and an increase in compensation to R$1 million.
The judgment of the appeal resulted in a vote in favor of the businessman. Judge Tetsuzo Namba, rapporteur of the case, defended the maintenance of the conviction, considering the evidence sufficient to confirm the initial sentence. However, his vote was surpassed by judges Francisco Orlando and Alex Zilenovski, who formed the majority for acquittal.
Legal basis for the acquittal decision
When explaining his vote, judge Francisco Orlando argued that the elements collected during the procedural investigation were not sufficient to dispel the uncertainties regarding the dynamics of the events and the lack of consent from the victim. The judge emphasized that, in the face of significant doubts, the legal principle of *in dubio pro reo* — which determines that doubt must favor the accused — should prevail.
Among the points considered by the panel were witness reports, which indicated that the woman did not appear incapacitated in the restaurant or upon arrival at the hotel. Also taken into account were inconsistencies regarding the presence of an armed security guard at the bedroom door and images captured the day after the meeting, which were interpreted by the judges as inconsistent with the prosecution’s version.
In the opinion of the majority of judges, these factors considerably weakened the accusatory thesis, preventing the formation of a conviction solid enough to sustain the criminal conviction.






