Donald Trump must pay $5.8 million to writer after US Supreme Court ruling

A decision by the Federal Court of Manhattan, in the United States, authorized this Wednesday (8) the transfer of US$5.8 million (equivalent to R$29.8 million) from Donald Trump to the writer E. Jean Carroll. The former Republican president was found guilty of sexual abuse and defamation in a civil case that took place in 2023.
E. Jean Carroll, who was an advice columnist for Elle magazine, alleges that she was raped by Trump in mid-1996 inside a dressing room at a department store in New York.
Trump had previously deposited the entire amount into an escrow account while awaiting the ruling on his appeal. However, on June 29, the US Supreme Court rejected the request to analyze the case, making the decision final and binding.
In a document presented last Tuesday night (7) to the Manhattan Federal Court, the former president’s legal team had argued that Carroll should await a new analysis of the conviction by the Supreme Court before receiving the amount. The original compensation of US$5 million had an increase in interest, reaching the current US$5.8 million.
According to Trump’s defenders, there would be “irreparable harm” and an “inestimable loss” if Carroll carried out his intention to donate the money. The central argument was that, once the resources were distributed, it would be practically impossible to recover them if the court decision was reversed in future instances.
Trump’s lawyers also argued that allowing immediate payment, before any review by the Supreme Court, could “undermine public confidence in an orderly judicial process.” They mentioned that, in their view, Trump supporters and some of his critics express concern about what they consider a “political instrumentalization of the justice system.”
“Carroll waited more than 20 years to falsely accuse Donald Trump, whom she politically opposes, until after he became the 45th president, when she could maximize political damage to him and profit for herself,” said the Republican’s legal representatives.
Details of the abuse report made by the writer in her memoirs
Trump and Carroll have been involved in a legal dispute since 2019, when the writer released an excerpt from her memoir. In it, she narrates having been raped by the then businessman around 1996, in a fitting room at Bergdorf Goodman, a department store located in Manhattan, New York.
The former president consistently denied Carroll’s allegations, saying she lied about the events. He maintained this position both in 2019, during his first term, and in 2022, after leaving the presidency.
In May, the United States Department of Justice announced the opening of a criminal investigation into Carroll. This measure, also taken against other critics of Trump, aims to determine whether the writer committed perjury in statements related to the two civil cases she won against the former president.






