The new live-action version of ‘Moana’ fails to innovate, but Dwayne Johnson stands out

The live-actionMoana, which opened in theaters on Wednesday, July 8, 2026, introduces audiences to the same independent princess who won over everyone in the original 2016 animation.
Disney’s decision to turn this blockbuster into a live-action version in less than a decade might seem like an audacious move at first glance.
However, in practice, the studio delivered an already widely known experience, recreating scene by scene from the original film without adding significant elements to the narrative.
For animation admirers, this fidelity can be interpreted not as a problem, but as a positive point, generating a feeling of relief among fans.
After all, live-action adaptations are often evaluated by the balance between presenting something new, which justifies a new entry, and preserving the essence of the source material.
The central story of the adventure remains untouched
Even though the live-action brings little new, it preserves what has always been the great charm ofMoana: its engaging narrative.
On the island of Motunui, where her father exercises leadership, Moana grew up aware that one day she would assume that position, without the need for marriage to a prince.
The plot unfolds when an ancient curse threatens neighboring islands, reaching their own people and directly affecting fishing and farming.
Faced with this fate as a leader, it is up to Moana to embark on a journey across the ocean in search of a solution to save her community.
The real attraction ofMoanait was always the character’s journey, not just the outcome of the story. The beauty and challenges of this epic adventure are what truly captivate the viewer.
The film portrays a beautiful journey of a young girl in search of her identity, understanding her purpose and who she is destined to be.
Dwayne Johnson’s charisma stands out in the film
In this quest, the interaction between Moana and the demigod Maui continues to be one of the strongest points of the production.
The demigod, played by Dwayne Johnson, an actor with a striking presence in every sense, takes on the role of mentor, traveling partner and essential figure in the protagonist’s heroic journey.
With a personality that oscillates between selfishness and kindness, Maui displays traits that position him as a hero and an antagonist.
At first, he even imprisons Moana and tries to get away from her on several occasions. However, throughout the story, he gives in to the young woman’s arguments, and the relationship between them evolves, revealing a vulnerability behind the demigod’s armor.
Even in animation, Johnson already lent his charisma to the character with just his voice. Now, in live-action, he has the chance to fully embody it on screen.
The actor demonstrates total dominance in all his appearances, making Maui less surly, especially in the initial scenes, and more witty and charismatic.
The result is a character with sharp comic timing and moments for jokes with a more adult tone, which please the audience.
Moana’s performance falls short of expectations
Catherine Lagaʻaia faces the difficult task of playing a character who, in the animated version, won over the audience with her charisma and strong personality.
Although the actress maintains Moana’s fearless essence, her interpretation delivers a less magnetic version compared to the original.
Lagaʻaia is also responsible for the songs in the English version of the film and, unlike his less vibrant performance, manages to fulfill his vocal role well. For animation fans, the songs continue to shine.
Visual effects don’t match the beauty of animation
The same cannot be said for the stunning landscapes present in the animation. The live-action, visually, presents a great disappointment.
The attempt to recreate the lush beaches and mountains of Polynesia is compromised by the excessive use of digital effects.
The ocean, which is a crucial element in the story, loses part of its charm in certain interactions that seem excessively artificial.
Small changes to address current debates
One of the few changes that the live-action introduces is an adjustment to the narrative to dialogue with contemporary discussions about feminism and representation, themes that were already present in the 2016 work.
In the animated version, Moana’s father talks about his daughter’s destiny following the tradition of “her father and her grandfather”, emphasizing a male lineage.
In the new adaptation, the film incorporates a female ancestor among the island’s ancient leaders, suggesting that Moana would not necessarily be the first woman to command her village.
There is yet another subtle and humorous nod coming from Maui. When presenting himself as a hero, he promptly corrects his speech to state that he is the hero “of women and men, without discrimination”.
These are succinct changes that do not change the course of history and may even go unnoticed, but that update details of the speech for the 2026 audience.
The new version does not add anything innovative
In the end, the live-actionMoanaboils down to a flesh-and-blood reproduction, with a lot of green screen, of a story that was already powerful in itself, without offering anything beyond that.
The adventure maintains its emotion, the songs remain unforgettable, and Moana remains an essential protagonist in the formation of the identity of children, both girls and boys.
The question that remains is: if everything was already in its place and there was nothing to add, was it really necessary to make this new version?






