Apple and Epic Games disagree on suspension of App Store commissions court case

Epic Games recently spoke out against Apple’s request, which seeks to interrupt the legal process between the two companies in the United States. The technology giant asked for the case to be stopped in the first instance, waiting for the country’s Supreme Court to examine an appeal regarding the application of external payments in the App Store.
Previously, the Ninth Circuit Court had ruled that the fees applied by Apple to satisfy the initial judgment would need to be reevaluated in new “return procedures.” The court considered that the company’s commissions, as they were similar to those charged on the App Store itself, could constitute disrespect for the original judicial determination.
Disagreeing with this decision, Apple appealed to the Supreme Court, seeking to overturn the Ninth Circuit’s determination. As the appeal was accepted for analysis, the company now wants the “return procedures” to be carried out only after deliberation by the highest court. This was the basis for the request sent to Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers.

In compliance with its right of reply, Epic Games contested Apple’s request. The game developer asked the judge to deny the stay request and order the process to continue, ensuring that Apple’s commission assessments are finally carried out as the Ninth Circuit instructed.
Epic argued that the Ninth Circuit had already established that regardless of whether the Supreme Court ruled that Apple did not commit a miscarriage of justice, commission review procedures would still be necessary. The developer suggests that such revisions would likely be similar, or even identical, whatever the higher court’s verdict.
Apple’s arguments against continuing the case
In its counterargument, Apple refuted Epic’s statements, which considered the Supreme Court’s analysis irrelevant. The technology company stated that Epic’s allegations are based on “incorrect premises”. For Apple, the accusation of disrespecting the injunction is the only pillar for the commissions’ review, as it indicates an alleged violation of the initial decision.
The apple company argued that a Supreme Court verdict could have a substantial impact on the entire litigation. Additionally, Apple contended that Epic incorrectly interpreted previous Ninth Circuit deliberations, such as the denial of the request to lift the injunction. This scenario, according to Apple, differs from the current request for a provisional suspension of the case’s “return procedures”.
Apple’s counter-response, submitted this week, represents the final step before judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers makes a final decision on the application. If the suspension request is denied, the company will have 24 hours to submit its proposal for the implementation of commissions on external purchases, in accordance with the “feedback procedures” established by the Ninth Circuit.






