Chelsea bets on Manchester City athletes; club seeks profits and new talents

Not only were Chelsea beaten by Manchester City in the 2020 FA Youth Cup final, but they also found a vision for their own future in their rival’s youth teams. The situation is so evident that Chelsea’s first team, next season, will be able to count on twice as many athletes coming from City’s academy compared to the talents trained in its own base.
The most recent acquisition is that of Morgan Rogers, whose £117 million value represents a club record, and who, six years earlier, had found the net against the Blues’ under-18 team. Cole Palmer, another accomplished player in City’s academy, also contributed one of the goals in City’s 3-2 victory at St George’s Park, while Liam Delap excelled in the attacking department. Additionally, new Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso’s group of players includes Romeo Lavia, Jamie Gittens and Tosin Adarabioyo, all of whom have also developed at City’s youth level.
Added to Rogers, Palmer and Delap, these six athletes total almost 300 million pounds in transfer fees disbursed by Chelsea since 2023. In contrast, Alonso should have only three names in his main squad coming from Chelsea’s academy in Cobham on a permanent basis: Levi Colwill, who was on the field in that defeat, captain Reece James and defender Josh Acheampong. Trevoh Chalobah also remains a Chelsea player, but is in advanced negotiations over a possible move to Italian Serie A club Como.
Chelsea’s attraction to City-trained players has several reasons, including Palmer’s remarkable performance. He joined in 2023 for £40m, with an additional £2.5m in bonuses, and quickly established himself as one of the Premier League’s big names. According to a former City employee, any athlete who passes through the club’s structure “knows the standards of a good professional”. Another important member is Joe Shields, who previously worked in the recruitment department at City’s academy and is currently involved in both recruiting young talent and building the first team squad at Stamford Bridge. It’s a pattern that repeats itself: other teams also have former Manchester City employees, such as Manchester United, which has Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox in leadership positions.
Meanwhile, there is a strong incentive for clubs to negotiate players trained in their own youth categories. This is because transfer figures can be recorded as pure profit for accounting purposes, in line with Premier League and UEFA spending rules, which helps with Financial Fair Play compliance. The recent sale of Tyrique George from Chelsea to Everton during the summer illustrates this practice well. Former City coach Pep Guardiola had already admitted the difficulty in offering chances to players from the academy in a team that is always competing for the main trophies. Although athletes like Rogers were not seen as ready for professional football at first, others, including Palmer and Jadon Sancho, were offered contracts and squad opportunities, but preferred to pursue their growth elsewhere.
In the case of Chelsea, the sale of academy players has been a continuous need, both during Roman Abramovich’s management and, more recently, under the command of Todd Boehly and Clearlake Capital since 2022, in order to balance the large investments in new signings. Chelsea, instinctively, directed their attention to City’s youth teams in search of an ideal environment for young talent. The London club counts on the expertise of several former members of City’s coaching staff, such as Calum McFarlane, first team coach, and Glenn van der Kraan, who was recently promoted to academy director.
There was also a short stint by Tom Glick, a former City executive, as Chelsea’s business president, at the same time that Enzo Maresca, former Chelsea coach, and several members of his technical team had already worked at the Etihad. Maresca has even returned to City. Other additional connections exist between City’s academy and Chelsea. James McAtee and CJ Egan-Riley, both participants in the 2020 FA Youth Cup final, were already targets of Strasbourg, a French club that belongs to BlueCo, the holding company that owns Chelsea. Chelsea also expressed an interest in their former academy player Michael Olise – who had a spell at City – before his move to Bayern Munich, and on another occasion, considered signing defender Nico O’Reilly.
Chelsea concluded last season without winning any titles, finishing the Premier League in tenth place, but its youth teams, on the other hand, lifted championship and cup trophies. This scenario highlights the high quality of emerging talent under Shields and Van der Kraan, with youth development director Jack Francis ensuring continuity as he begins his sixteenth year at the club. Cobham’s academy was once run by Neil Bath and Jim Fraser, who established a successful model, capable of winning five FA Youth Cups in a row, including three consecutive victories over City, which equaled the all-time record set by Manchester United’s “Busby Babes” in the 1950s.
Furthermore, Chelsea were UEFA Youth League champions in 2015 and 2016, remaining the only English club to have lifted that trophy. However, Chelsea suffered a transfer ban in 2019 as a result of breaches relating to youth recruitment. The club currently faces restrictions on the registration of academy players, due to long-standing infractions that originated under the Abramovich administration. This first transfer restriction helped pave the way for names like Tammy Abraham, Mason Mount, Fikayo Tomori, Callum Hudson-Odoi, Ruben Loftus-Cheek, Andreas Christensen and Reece James to consolidate themselves in the first team under the guidance of Frank Lampard.
That was a golden period for Chelsea’s academy, as City, under Abu Dhabi management, expanded rapidly and invested massively in developing young talent, an area that was not subject to financial spending restrictions. The supremacy of the two academies was so remarkable that they maintained an informal pact not to sign players from each other, with the aim of avoiding excessive increases in salaries and transfer fees in the youth teams. However, this agreement was scrapped.
Manchester United, Liverpool and Arsenal, in turn, also began a new cycle of investment in their respective youth categories after Brexit, which made it impossible to sign foreign players under the age of 18. It is important to note that Liverpool signed Rio Ngumoha, a current England youth player, from Chelsea in 2024. This resulted in restrictions on the presence of scouts from several rival clubs during games.
With Chelsea under new leadership, Bath were devising a new approach. However, after Fraser left the club due to a disagreement with key figures, Bath also left, and former City professionals were integrated into academy positions. This sudden change generated surprise in the world of grassroots football, where reports of fierce rivalries between the two clubs, intense disagreements behind the scenes and effusive celebrations after triumphs in the youth categories still echo. An authentic rivalry has been established between the two dominant training systems, one in the north and the other in the south, over the last decade.
When asked about the rivalry in 2025, Delap stated categorically: “We hated each other in games.” He added: “But now everyone is mature enough that, off the field, we can maintain our friendship. I used to face Levi [Colwill] every year, and it was always a great contest. I have a lot of matches to remember, but we [City] came out victorious in the Youth Cup final [in 2020].”
Since that period, Chelsea has implemented significant changes to its training methodology. Dozens of new professionals were hired, and those who were already at the club had to adjust to these transformations. Gareth Taylor, coach of the Liverpool women’s team, with nine years’ experience at City’s academy, recalls how former Barcelona manager Rodolfo Borrell was instrumental in implementing a training philosophy that took inspiration from Johan Cruyff and Guardiola.
Taylor described Delap as a player with “incredible spirit”, Rogers as “very good and very humble”, and Palmer as an athlete who “used to dribble past opponents with ease” and “never showed nervousness”. Taylor emphasized: “We developed a very defined style of play. From the under-11 and under-12 categories up to the under-23s, there was a clear coherence in the way we acted, in our identity and in our method.” The revolution driven by City’s model has had a noticeable impact on both the senior and youth teams at Stamford Bridge. Currently, with the arrival of Alonso, Chelsea hopes that this new approach will generate even more positive results.






