Italian court consults EU justice and may review citizenship rules for descendants

The Constitutional Court of Italy decided, on July 23, 2026, to request the analysis of a European Union court on the restrictions imposed on granting citizenship to foreigners. This measure, unexpected for many jurists, opens up the possibility of a turnaround in the recent legislative changes that impacted thousands of Italian descendants around the world, including a large number of Brazilians.
The court’s decision represents a new stage in a process that has generated intense discussion. The consultation with the European court seeks to clarify whether the new limitations on citizenship constitute an undue revocation of rights or whether they are legitimate criteria to determine who can receive nationality. Furthermore, the Italian court wants to know whether the law is in line with the norms and ideals that govern the European Union, of which Italy is part.
Surprising development in Italian justice
The move by the Italian Constitutional Court surprised the legal community, especially because the court itself had previously signaled that it saw no need to take the case to European bodies. The change in this decision indicates a reassessment of the complexity of the issue and its potential conflict with broader principles.
The judges now want an opinion on the compatibility of the restrictions with European law. The central question is whether the changes, which tighten the conditions for the recognition of citizenship, can be considered a violation of fundamental rights guaranteed to European Union citizens, or whether they are within the sovereignty of each member state to define their own nationality policies.
The impact of restrictions and criticism of the new law
Changes in citizenship legislation generated a wave of indignation, especially in countries like Brazil and Argentina, which have a large contingent of Italian descendants. Thousands of great-grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren, who previously had the right to citizenship guaranteed, may now lose this possibility.
Critics of the new rules argue that granting Italian citizenship without generational limits has always been a constitutional right, seen as a historic reparation for the millions of Italians who emigrated in search of better living conditions in the past. The restriction, for them, disregards this heritage and the cultural bond maintained by many families for generations.
Understand current rules and previous legislation
Current legislation, approved by the Italian Parliament in 2025, established significant new limits for granting citizenship. Currently, the right is restricted to children and grandchildren of Italians, and only under two specific conditions:
- If the father, mother, grandfather or grandmother was born in Italy or was recognized as an Italian citizen at the time of death.
- If the father, mother, grandfather or grandmother with Italian citizenship, born outside Italy, has lived in the country for at least two consecutive years before the birth of the child or grandchild.
Before the 2025 decree came into force, Italy operated under the legal principle of “jus sanguinis” – or “right of blood”. This principle guaranteed the nationality of a country to the child of a citizen of that country, regardless of place of birth. In the Italian case, this right could be transmitted without limit of generations, simply proving the link with an Italian ancestor who was alive after March 17, 1861, the date of the creation of the Kingdom of Italy.
Italy’s “virtual citizenships” argument
At the beginning of the year, when deciding to maintain the new rules restricting the granting of nationality, the Constitutional Court justified the measure by stating that the previous rules had created a “multitude of foreigners with virtual citizenship”.
In their ruling, the judges argued that the massive migratory phenomenon, combined with the absence of limits on the transmission of citizenship by affiliation, generated many individuals with a “‘virtual’ Italian citizenship, while not certified”. The court also pointed out that Italian legislation was becoming “isolated” compared to standards in other European countries, which have been adjusted over the years to reflect demographic and social realities.
For the Constitutional Court, the new rules do not violate the Constitution or European Union law, as they consider an “effective link between the citizen and the Republic” to be fundamental. Democratic participation and the sharing of political destinies, according to the ruling, are rooted in this real connection between citizens and the national community.
The role of the Court of the European Union in the decision
Consulting a European Union court is a procedural step that can have great weight in the final interpretation of Italian law. Although decisions by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) do not automatically annul a national law, its interpretations on the compatibility of domestic legislation with European law are highly influential and generally accepted by the courts of member states.
The CJEU will analyze the issue from the perspective of European Union treaties and principles, such as the principle of non-discrimination, freedom of movement and the fundamental rights of European citizens. A possible recommendation to lift or modify the restrictions would force Italy to reevaluate its legislation, potentially reestablishing access to citizenship for a greater number of descendants.






