BMW driver ordered to pay R$2 million after death of teenager in Paraná; ‘It doesn’t bring happiness, nor my son back’, says father

The parents of Anthony Pietro, who died in a car accident, will receive more than R$2 million in compensation. They see the driver’s conviction as a victory for justice, although they emphasize that the decision does not alleviate the pain caused by the loss of their son.
The person responsible for paying the compensation is Maria do Carmo Carneiro, aged 78, who was driving the BMW involved in the fatal accident.
“It’s another battle won, it brings a little feeling that justice is being done, but this money doesn’t bring us happiness and, unfortunately, neither does my son back”, declared Luiz Thiago Rosa, Anthony’s father.
The accident that killed 14-year-old Anthony occurred on November 24, 2024, on the PR-558 highway, in Campo Mourão, in the Central-West region of Paraná. The teenager returned home with his father after taking an entrance exam.
Maria do Carmo was arrested in the act and charged with intentional homicide with possible intent, aggravated culpable bodily harm, driving under the influence of alcohol and driving with a suspended driver’s license.
The driver can still appeal against the sentence in the civil sphere. Additionally, Maria do Carmo must face trial by a popular jury in the criminal court, a decision that was appealed by her defense and is awaiting analysis.
“The intention has always been to weigh heavily on this civil matter, with the aim of punishing her, as we know that, given her age today, the criminal case will not be as strict”, explained Thiago, in a strategic view of the search for reparation.
The court, when delivering the sentence, considered the amount requested by the family’s lawyers to be compatible with the financial capacity of the accused. “The defendant’s considerable economic capacity […] allows the establishment of a compensation amount that effectively fulfills the compensatory, punitive and preventive functions of civil liability, without compromising the defendant’s subsistence”, states the court document.
Luiz Thiago Rosa reported that his wife still suffers deeply from the loss of her son and is undergoing psychological and psychiatric treatment. The couple’s youngest daughter, aged 9, also feels her brother’s absence.
“May this lady’s conviction serve as an example for society and for our authorities to look more closely at cases of deaths due to drunk driving, and for the penalties to be exemplary and rigorous”, concluded the father.
Details of the conviction for moral and material damages
The decision was handed down by judge Marco Antonio dos Santos, from the Peabiru Civil Court. The sentence confirmed the driver’s guilt for the accident, pointing to excessive speed, improper overtaking and strong evidence of drunkenness.
The court ordered the payment of R$2 million for moral damages, an amount to be divided between Anthony’s father and mother. Maria do Carmo was also ordered to pay R$31,257.76 for material damages, covering hospital expenses and the teenager’s funeral.
However, the judge rejected the requests for lifetime pension, future psychological and psychiatric treatment and other compensation, considering that the family was not financially dependent on the young man.
Maria do Carmo’s lawyer was contacted and informed that he would not comment on the conviction.
The foundations of the court ruling
The content of the sentence reveals that the judge based his decision on the expert report and a technical opinion contracted by Anthony’s family.
Both technical reports indicated that the BMW invaded the opposite lane, traveling at a speed much higher than permitted. The reports showed that the vehicle reached 137 km/h, with the road limit being 80 km/h.
The violence of the impact was such that the BMW’s engine was ripped out and the vehicle caught fire on the sides of the highway.
The driver’s defense tried to argue, based on its own technical opinion, that Maria do Carmo’s vision would have been obscured by the sun on a curve. However, this argument was rejected by the judge, who identified technical flaws and found that the witnesses’ testimony contradicted the accused’s version.
Furthermore, evidence of Maria do Carmo’s drunkenness was presented. According to the document, nurses and Anthony’s father reported that she gave off an ethyl odor and demonstrated “harsh and unrealistic behavior.” The driver also refused to take a breathalyzer test after the intervention of a family doctor during hospital care.
During the investigations, the police also confirmed, through consultations with security and traffic systems, that the driver had a suspended National Driving License (CNH). Documents attached to the process indicated that the suspension occurred due to the recurrence and accumulation of traffic infractions of a serious and very serious nature, including speeding and dangerous driving, demonstrating a history of reckless conduct behind the wheel.
Recalling the details of the accident
Thiago, Anthony’s father, reported that he was unable to avoid the driver’s car, which, according to him, was traveling at high speed and traveling along the road in a zigzag pattern.
The impact was so severe that the BMW’s engine was ripped out, and the vehicle ended up catching fire on the side of the highway.
The father explained that he and his son were returning to Araruna, where they lived. They had gone to Campo Mourão so that the teenager could take a test to enter technical education at the Federal Technological University of Paraná (UTFPR).
“He died with the answer sheet in his hand. Before, he said ‘dad, I think I passed’. He just wanted to study”, lamented his father.
According to his family, Anthony was a calm teenager, with a talent for music, he liked to play guitar, guitar and drums.
He also enjoyed skateboarding and watching football matches. The young man left behind his parents and a younger sister.







