Legal dispute between Apple and OpenAI intensifies over employee departure and trade secrets

OpenAI refuted Apple’s allegations that former employees had stolen trade secrets when they ended their activities at the technology giant. In a petition sent to the United States Court in July, the startup argues that Apple did not present concrete evidence of the theft of confidential data.
The controversy revolves around the hiring of experts for OpenAI’s hardware sector and signals a deepening tension between the companies, which had previously established a collaboration to integrate ChatGPT into Apple devices.
Documents related to the process indicate that approximately 400 professionals who worked for Apple were recruited by OpenAI for its hardware development venture.
Apple points out appropriation of data by former employees
Apple filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and its former employees, Tang Tan and Chang Liu, during the month of July. The tech giant maintains that the pair misappropriated crucial information about equipment design, manufacturing processes and its entire supply chain.
OpenAI, on the other hand, interprets legal action differently. The company perceives the process as an effort to contain its expansion as a potential rival and to discourage Apple employees from seeking new opportunities. As recorded in the case records, around 400 individuals who were at the manufacturer were incorporated into the OpenAI hardware area.
“This controversy was generated by Apple itself, and it tries to assign blame to everyone,” OpenAI stated.
The artificial intelligence startup also argues that California state legislation guarantees workers the right to leave one organization to join another, even if both operate in the same market segment.
Access to internal documents becomes focus of litigation
Apple insists that Tan and Liu accessed confidential company materials after their contracts ended. For the manufacturer, this action would be part of an OpenAI plan to acquire strategic data.
OpenAI disputed this claim, citing Apple’s own employee termination protocols. The company argues that these procedures could make it difficult to distinguish between personal documents and corporate files.
- Permission for employees to use their personal iCloud accounts to access professional documents;
- The abrupt removal of employees from the facilities, which would shorten the deadline for returning corporate devices;
- The possibility that internal files were not fully transferred back to the company before dismissal;
- The difficulty in transitioning responsibilities, which could be compromised.
Liu, in turn, stated that he accessed some documents after his departure to help former colleagues find files and clarify doubts about his former roles. He reported that Apple collaborators continued to request his support.
Former employees present their defense and counter accusations
Tang Tan, with 24 years of service at Apple, assured that he had delivered all the prototypes before leaving the company. He stated that he only retained non-confidential materials, such as a checklist used in employee termination procedures.
“Professionals can leave a company like Apple, which faced challenges in implementing artificial intelligence, to join an innovative and exciting startup that creates cutting-edge products,” said OpenAI.
The dynamics between the two companies underwent a rapid transformation. Approximately two years ago, Apple and OpenAI sealed an agreement with the aim of expanding ChatGPT’s reach and strengthening the manufacturer’s position in the competitive artificial intelligence market.
Currently, with OpenAI expanding into the hardware sector and attracting talent from Apple, this old partnership has given way to a legal clash. The dispute now focuses on trade secrets, hiring processes and companies’ internal rules.






