Alexandre de Moraes sends Fachin a request to investigate minister André Mendonça for misconduct in the STF

Minister Alexandre de Moraes, of the Federal Supreme Court (STF), sent to the President of the Court, Minister Edson Fachin, a request for an investigation to be initiated against his colleague André Mendonça. The initiative was taken on September 3, 2026, in the context of the fake news inquiry, and puts Mendonça under scrutiny for several serious allegations.
Moraes points out signs of irregularities in the performance of his role
In the petition, Moraes detailed strong evidence that Mendonça had committed acts of administrative improbity, abuse of authority and criminal liability. Furthermore, suspicions of favoritism towards specific political groups were raised during the reporting of cases such as Master and INSS. The request for investigation highlights the seriousness of the accusations, which touch on the impartiality and legality of the actions of a Supreme Court magistrate.
Federal Police report details direction of investigations
Minister Alexandre de Moraes’ decision is based on a report from the Federal Police (PF), which indicates that André Mendonça had “usurped” the direction of police investigations. The document suggests that Mendonça conducted whistleblower negotiations irregularly and directed investigations to specific targets, including Moraes himself and the president of the Senate, Davi Alcolumbre, for “personal and political reasons”. This action, according to the report, would indicate a “flagrant loss of impartiality” on the part of the minister.
Alleged manipulation of evidence and benefits in plea bargains
- Moraes listed crucial points from the PF report, which include:
- The usurpation of the investigative direction of the police authorities, with administrative measures that would have harmed the chain of custody and the production of evidence.
- The irregular conduct of negotiations for a possible award-winning collaboration, involving contacts with defenders of would-be collaborators.
- The proposition of extralegal benefits, without provision in law, which would place the Federal Police as a proponent of such advantages.
According to Minister Alexandre de Moraes, the report also points out that Mendonça’s actions resulted in “the role of a judge as an investigator”. The decision adds that, “as highlighted by the Federal Police, ‘the required format is, in itself, indicative: it is intended for consultation and analysis of content’, allowing the reporting Minister to select, suppress or manipulate documentation in flagrant breach of the chain of custody”.
PF intelligence documents reveal asymmetry and political targets
Federal Police intelligence reports, cited by Moraes, indicate differentiated treatment applied by Mendonça to authorities in similar situations. An excerpt from these documents, according to Moraes, states that Mendonça adopts “very different positions in the face of illegality” in relation to ministers Dias Toffoli and Nunes Marques.
Another document, also cited by Moraes, describes an “asymmetry across the political spectrum” and mentions that “the rapporteur, Minister André Mendonça, determined – OFFICE – police investigative measures for the illegal production of evidence against Minister Alexandre de Moraes, with the exceptional aggravating circumstance of having ordered the Federal Police to carry out the investigation without having signed the judicial decision and without having communicated it through legal procedural means, as well as having withheld the knowledge of the same from the Attorney General’s Office”. The report points out that Davi Alcolumbre could be a “probable strategic target” of Mendonça, aiming to control the Senate agenda regarding requests for impeachment of STF ministers.
Mendonça tried to remove directors from the Federal Police and PGR, points out Moraes
Alexandre de Moraes also mentioned that the report indicated that André Mendonça had tried to remove the director general of the PF, Andrei Rodrigues, and the attorney general of the Republic, Paulo Gonet. Rodrigues would be targeted for his alleged proximity to President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, while Gonet would be targeted for his connection with Minister Gilmar Mendes.
PGR had questioned a previous investigation conducted by Mendonça
On September 1, 2026, the Attorney General’s Office (PGR) had already declared the nullity of an investigation ordered by André Mendonça. This investigation had revealed messages and contacts between Moraes and the former owner of Banco Master, Daniel Vorcaro. The messages in the PF report also point to the proximity between Attorney General Paulo Gonet and Vorcaro. To date, minister André Mendonça has not publicly commented on the accusations.






