Supreme Court gives Mendonça 72 hours over police leadership

Supremo Tribunal Federal President Edson Fachin gave Justice André Mendonça a 72-hour deadline on September 8, 2026, to provide formal clarifications regarding an injunction request filed by the federal government against the removal of the head of the Polícia Federal in Brasília. This preliminary consultation must occur before the leadership of the court issues any administrative ruling on the dispute.
The Advocacia-Geral da União submitted the petition to the court presidency on September 8, 2026, seeking to overturn the unilateral decision issued by André Mendonça that ordered the preventive removal of Andrei Rodrigues from his post as director-general.
Solicitor General Jorge Messias signed the legal document delivered to the Supremo Tribunal Federal. The text argues that the judicial removal causes “grave lesão à ordem pública e administrativa.” The agency urged immediate action.
Government lawyers argued that removing the director directly violates the exclusive constitutional authority granted to the President of the Republic to appoint and dismiss commanders of the Polícia Federal. The petition stresses that this executive power cannot face judicial interference without concrete statutory justification.
In an official announcement, the Advocacia-Geral da União stated that “a descontinuidade abrupta na gestão do órgão compromete o funcionamento das atividades de polícia judiciária e gera risco de desorganização institucional” while underscoring direct harm to ongoing field operations.
The filed legal rationale specifies that selecting, appointing, and discharging the director of the Polícia Federal belongs entirely to the executive branch. Executive prerogative governs the post.
The government legal body emphasized the critical timing of the request. “Diante do quadro de urgência, a AGU requereu a concessão de liminar para suspender imediatamente o afastamento dos dirigentes e a subsequente confirmação do pedido no mérito até manifestação definitiva do órgão competente,” the institution stated. Court officials registered the filing under urgent procedures.
Brazilian law establishes that holding the rank of special class delegate within the Polícia Federal serves as the sole statutory qualification required to lead the police agency.
Justice André Mendonça directed the suspension order against both Andrei Rodrigues and intelligence director Leandro Almada da Costa following an internal investigation into allegations that departmental officers produced apocryphal intelligence reports to conduct clandestine monitoring operations against the magistrate himself and Solicitor General Jorge Messias during active federal proceedings. The investigation created deep internal friction.
During a preliminary review held in the virtual plenary of the Segunda Turma, Justices André Mendonça, Luiz Fux, and Nunes Marques formed a temporary majority of three votes to sustain the suspensions.
Justice Gilmar Mendes halted the voting process by filing a formal request to examine the case files. Because of this procedural suspension, the individual order issued by André Mendonça stays in force and bars Andrei Rodrigues from directing the police force.
Disciplinary inquiries ordered alongside internal police leadership changes
The ruling signed by André Mendonça instructed the Corregedoria of the Polícia Federal to open administrative disciplinary and criminal proceedings without delay. The investigations will scrutinize the compilation of intelligence files targeting public figures. Mendonça demanded fast findings.
The justice explicitly prohibited federal agents from drafting or circulating any intelligence summaries designed to monitor the professional activities of judges, federal public defenders, or judicial police officers.
The Associação Nacional dos Peritos Criminais Federais, representing federal forensics experts, issued a formal release calling for the matter to head immediately to the full 10-member bench of the Supremo Tribunal Federal. The association urged broader collegiate review.
Members of the high command of the Polícia Federal declared “total apoio” for Andrei Rodrigues and transferred operational responsibilities to delegate William Marcel Murad, who assumed leadership as acting director-general while the transition remains underway.






