Archbishop of Canterbury rescinds interfaith honor to Muslim leader following unearthed remarks praising Osama bin Laden
The office of the Archbishop of Canterbury has officially withdrawn a significant interfaith award previously bestowed upon a prominent Muslim cleric, Maulana Hafiz Muhammad Tahir Mehmood Ashrafi. The decision came swiftly after past comments attributed to the cleric, in which he appeared to commend Osama bin Laden, resurfaced publicly.
Ashrafi had received the Hubert Walter Award for Reconciliation and Interfaith Cooperation at London’s historic Lambeth Palace just last Friday. This ceremony, intended to celebrate efforts in fostering religious harmony, coincidentally occurred on the 25th anniversary of the September 11 terrorist attacks, adding a layer of sensitivity to the revelations.
Lambeth Palace reconsiders and revokes recognition
Lambeth Palace, the official residence of the Archbishop of Canterbury, announced the revocation on Thursday, stating that earlier remarks made by Imam Ashrafi had “come to light,” prompting a thorough reconsideration of the award. The institution underscored its commitment to the foundational principle of interfaith dialogue, emphasizing the necessity of engaging across deeply held differences.
Despite this commitment, the newly revealed comments were deemed serious enough to warrant the withdrawal. A statement from Lambeth Palace confirmed the decision, noting that Imam Ashrafi had been informed directly. The institution also reiterated its prayers for the Christian community in Pakistan and for all individuals globally dedicated to promoting interfaith dialogue and harmony.
The controversial statements and their defense
The core of the controversy stems from comments attributed to Ashrafi in 2007. According to reports, he had then stated that Osama bin Laden, the mastermind behind the 9/11 attacks, “had been fighting for Islam against the Russians, Americans and British.” Furthermore, Ashrafi reportedly expressed his willingness to bestow upon bin Laden the honorific title “Saifullah,” meaning “Sword of God.”
These remarks, made years ago, gained renewed scrutiny following the recent award ceremony. When confronted with the resurfaced statements, Ashrafi asserted that his comments had been “totally taken out of context,” describing the subsequent backlash as an “unfair campaign.” He offered an explanation for his 2007 remarks, linking them to a period of heightened sensitivity among many Muslims. He claimed they were a response to the “hurt felt by many Muslims” over the British government’s decision to knight Salman Rushdie, the author of “The Satanic Verses,” a book widely considered blasphemous by some Islamic scholars.
Initial honor and broader implications for dialogue
The Hubert Walter Award for Reconciliation and Interfaith Cooperation was initially presented to Maulana Ashrafi in recognition of his extensive work. Lambeth Palace had highlighted his “longstanding support for religious minorities in Pakistan,” specifically mentioning the Christian community, and praised his “outstanding work as an ambassador of interfaith harmony” known for his dedication to promoting religious tolerance.
The withdrawal of the award underscores the delicate balance inherent in interfaith engagement, particularly when past actions or statements by participants come into conflict with the core values of reconciliation and peace. This incident highlights the challenges faced by religious institutions in vetting honorees and navigating the complexities of historical contexts and controversial figures.
For organizations like the Archbishop of Canterbury’s office, fostering dialogue often involves engaging with diverse leaders, some of whom may have complex public records. This episode serves as a reminder of the continuous need for vigilance and discernment in such endeavors, ensuring that recognition aligns unequivocally with principles of peace and mutual respect, especially in a world still grappling with the legacies of terrorism and religious extremism.






