Colin Kaepernick’s book tour faces scrutiny over unchallenged claims and unexamined career choices
Former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick has recently been highly visible across various media platforms, engaging in interviews to promote his new book, “The Perilous Fight.” His appearances included prominent shows such as “The View,” “The Daily Show,” and “The Pivot,” featuring discussions with hosts like Trevor Noah and Jemele Hill, among others.
However, these extensive media engagements have drawn considerable attention not just for what was discussed, but for what was notably absent: a perceived lack of challenging or critical questions directed at Kaepernick regarding some of his more controversial statements and actions over the past decade. This approach has led to observations about the generally uncritical nature of the interviews.
Controversial comparisons and career aspirations
During his promotional tour, Kaepernick reiterated a controversial comparison between the NFL’s player combine and a slave auction. He drew a parallel by noting that players are instructed to “strip down to your drawers” during the evaluation process. This assertion has been met with skepticism by many, particularly given the voluntary nature of NFL participation and the league’s role in creating numerous Black millionaires.
The juxtaposition of this comparison with Kaepernick’s stated desire to return to the NFL has also raised questions. Despite equating the league’s evaluation process to a brutal system of human exploitation, he has publicly maintained that he trains daily in anticipation of a call from an NFL team. This stance highlights a perceived inconsistency between his strong criticisms of the league and his ambition to rejoin its ranks, prompting observers to question the sincerity of his long-term career goals versus his activist identity.
Rhetoric on law enforcement and societal impact
Kaepernick has played a significant role in public discourse surrounding law enforcement, particularly through his protests and rhetoric in the mid-2010s and again in 2020. His actions included wearing socks depicting police officers as pigs and comparing law enforcement personnel to “modern-day slave patrols.” Critics argue that such rhetoric contributed to a broader vilification of police across the country.
This narrative, some suggest, had tangible consequences. A study by Harvard economics professor Roland Fryer, published approximately six years ago, identified a direct correlation between highly publicized police killings and a subsequent reduction in police contacts within affected cities. The research indicated that increased scrutiny and criticism led officers to become more hesitant, fearing mistakes that could lead to negative media attention. The resulting decrease in proactive policing was linked to significant increases in murder rates within Black communities.
- Wearing “pig socks” in public, symbolizing police as oppressive figures.
- Publicly comparing police officers to historical “slave patrols.”
- Issuing statements that critics argue contributed to widespread distrust and hostility towards law enforcement.
The phenomenon was particularly evident following the death of George Floyd in 2020, when widespread negative stereotyping of police officers coincided with a surge of approximately 2,500 additional murder victims in the Black community compared to the previous year. While Kaepernick was not solely responsible, his prominent role in shaping public perception is seen by some as embodying a mentality that contributed to these tragic outcomes, challenging the notion of his activism as uniformly peaceful.
Questionable protest rhetoric and on-field performance
Kaepernick’s public statements have also drawn scrutiny, particularly during periods of intense social unrest. For instance, a tweet he posted during the spring of 2020, amidst protests that included instances of violence and significant property damage, stated: “When civility leads to death, revolting is the only logical reaction. The cries for people will rain down, and when they do, they will land on deaf ears, because your violence has brought this resistance.” Such declarations are viewed by some as endorsing or inciting civil unrest rather than advocating for peaceful resolution, further complicating his “peaceful protester” image.
Beyond his activism, Kaepernick’s professional football career trajectory also warrants examination. In his final season as a starter with the San Francisco 49ers, he recorded a 1-10 win-loss record, completed less than 60% of his passes, and posted a QBR of 49.2. While he demonstrated some positive statistics, throwing 16 touchdowns against four interceptions, his performance was generally not considered elite. This level of play, critics argue, was insufficient to compensate for the significant distraction his activism had become for NFL teams. Had his on-field performance been comparable to top-tier quarterbacks like Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady, or Drew Brees, it is widely believed he would have secured a roster spot despite the controversy.
The 2019 workout saga and perceived motives
A pivotal moment in Kaepernick’s post-NFL career occurred in November 2019, when 25 NFL teams were expected to observe him at a workout hosted at the Atlanta Falcons’ facility. However, just hours before the scheduled event, Kaepernick unilaterally decided to change the location to a high school approximately 60 miles away, doing so without the league’s approval. He cited concerns over an insufficient liability waiver provided by the NFL as his reason for the last-minute relocation.
The league, which Kaepernick had previously sued for millions of dollars, countered that the waiver was standard procedure. This abrupt change, critics argue, placed the interested teams in a difficult position and ultimately led many to conclude that Kaepernick was not worth the additional trouble or logistical complications. It is suggested that Kaepernick, despite his claims of wanting to return to play, may have prioritized his narrative as an activist, which had already secured him a lucrative multi-million dollar endorsement deal with Nike. This perspective implies that the rigorous demands of a 16-game NFL season might have been less appealing than the continued notoriety and influence gained through his activism.






