US congress approves on february 26, 2025, law against Moraes, straining Brazil ties

On February 26, 2025, the Judiciary Committee of the US House of Representatives took a bold step that could reshape Brazil-US relations, approving the “No Censors on our Shores Act” with a commanding majority. This legislation, driven by Republicans loyal to President Donald Trump, who took office in January 2025, zeroes in on Brazilian Supreme Court (STF) Justice Alexandre de Moraes, accused of stifling free speech through his 2024 orders to suspend platforms like Elon Musk’s X in Brazil. The bill proposes severe penalties, including deportation and entry bans into the US, for foreign officials deemed to violate the First Amendment rights of American citizens. The vote, held under the leadership of Republican Jim Jordan, comes after months of escalating tensions sparked by Moraes’ judicial actions against disinformation and coup attempts, which have drawn ire from American conservatives and Bolsonaro supporters alike. Within hours, the US State Department fired off a social media statement, declaring that “respect for sovereignty is a two-way street,” a thinly veiled jab at Brazil’s government and judiciary. In Brazil, the decision has stirred a political whirlwind, with Bolsonaro allies cheering the move as a strike against the STF, while the Lula administration braces for a potential diplomatic standoff.
The bill’s journey is far from over, as it still needs the full House and Senate’s approval to become law, keeping Brasília on edge.
Moraes remains the focal point, his rulings against digital platforms now reverberating across borders with unprecedented intensity.
Heightened Friction Between Washington and Brasília
Drafted in September 2024 by Representatives María Elvira Salazar and Darrell Issa, the “No Censors on our Shores Act” gained traction after Trump’s November 2024 election victory. Its passage through the Judiciary Committee marks a triumph for the Republican agenda, which frames Moraes’ actions as an assault on American free speech principles.
Eduardo Bolsonaro, a key figure in Brazil’s opposition, visited Washington days before the vote, meeting with Trump-aligned lawmakers to rally support, a move seen as part of a broader strategy to undermine the STF and boost his father’s political prospects.
Elon Musk, whose X platform was at the heart of the 2024 dispute, posted a terse “Interesting” online after the vote, fueling speculation about his influence behind the scenes.
Roots and Ramifications of the Conflict
The clash began taking shape in August 2024, when Moraes ordered X’s suspension in Brazil for failing to appoint a local representative, a requirement under Brazilian law. The platform resumed operations weeks later after complying, but the episode galvanized criticism from Bolsonaro’s base and caught the attention of US conservatives. Trump’s January 2025 inauguration injected fresh momentum into the push against Moraes, with the Judiciary Committee vote on February 26 serving as a critical milestone. In Brazil, the Lula government views potential US sanctions on a sitting STF justice as a direct challenge to its authority, while the return of Rumble to the Brazilian market in February 2025, under new judicial scrutiny, has widened the scope of the dispute. The State Department’s swift reaction post-vote underscores the stakes, framing Brazil’s actions as incompatible with democratic norms shared by both nations.
Background of Moraes’ Judicial Role
Since 2023, Moraes has spearheaded STF efforts to curb disinformation, particularly after the January 8 riots tied to coup attempts. His 2024 decisions to block platforms like X and restrict accounts like Allan dos Santos’ sparked fierce backlash from Bolsonaro supporters.
Trump’s election shifted the narrative, with Republicans leveraging the free speech angle to target Moraes, culminating in the legislative push now unfolding in Congress.
Scope of the “No Censors on our Shores Act”
Born from the X suspension fallout, the bill seeks to punish foreign officials who limit American citizens’ online expression. The Judiciary Committee, chaired by Jim Jordan, pushed it through with a strong Republican majority.
Its next hurdles are votes in the full House and Senate, but the committee’s approval signals a firm US stance against Brazil’s judicial reach into American tech firms.
Historical Underpinnings of the Dispute
The STF’s crackdown on disinformation intensified in 2023, targeting networks linked to the January 8 unrest. By 2024, Moraes’ rulings had led to over 30 indictments, including one against Jair Bolsonaro in February 2025 for coup-related activities.
Daily fines of R$ 50,000 forced X’s compliance in 2024, amplifying debates over Brazil’s digital sovereignty and setting the stage for the US response.
Timeline of Key Developments
- August 2024: X suspended in Brazil under Moraes’ order.
- September 2024: Salazar and Issa introduce the bill in Congress.
- January 2025: Trump takes office, Eduardo Bolsonaro ramps up US visits.
- February 26, 2025: Judiciary Committee approves the bill after intense debate.
Scope and Reach of the Legislation
The bill singles out Moraes but could impact up to 650 individuals, drawing parallels to the Magnitsky Act’s sanctions since 2012. Its focus on free speech sets it apart, targeting judicial figures like Moraes.
In Brazil, it’s seen as an overreach into national affairs, while in the US, it reinforces Republican efforts to counter perceived global censorship.
State Department’s Diplomatic Volley
Hours after the vote, the State Department emphasized that fining US firms for not censoring content domestically contradicts democratic values, a pointed critique of Moraes’ rulings.
The statement serves as a warning shot to Brazil’s judiciary and government, amplifying the diplomatic stakes as the bill advances.
Bolsonaro-Trump Political Alignment
Eduardo Bolsonaro’s three trips to the US since January 2025 included meetings with Salazar, Issa, and Senator Rick Scott, forging ties to pressure the STF and bolster the Bolsonaro camp for 2026.
These efforts reflect a strategic alliance with Trump’s base, aiming to capitalize on the free speech narrative in both countries.
STF and Government Reactions
STF justices insist the US move won’t derail ongoing probes, such as Bolsonaro’s February 2025 indictment for coup attempts, maintaining focus on their judicial agenda.
The Lula administration, wary of a diplomatic crisis, monitors the situation closely but avoids public remarks that could escalate tensions with Trump’s team.
Intriguing Facets of the Standoff
Musk’s one-word reaction, “Interesting,” post-vote, keeps his role ambiguous, while Trump allies draw parallels between Moraes and the International Criminal Court, sanctioned by the US in prior years.
Rumble’s February 2025 return to Brazil reinstated controversial accounts like Allan dos Santos’, reigniting local debates over online expression limits.
The bill’s name, playing on “shores,” mirrors Trump’s nationalist rhetoric, framing it as a defense against foreign censorship.
Statistical Insights into the Dispute
X’s 2024 suspension disrupted millions of Brazilian users, while Rumble faces potential R$ 50,000 daily fines for non-compliance since its February 2025 return.
The Magnitsky Act precedent suggests the bill could target 650 individuals, with the Judiciary Committee vote securing about 70% support among members present.
Over 30 indictments stem from STF disinformation probes since 2023, with Bolsonaro’s case among the most prominent in February 2025.
Chronology of Escalating Events
August 2024 marked X’s suspension, reversed by September after compliance. That month, the bill emerged in Congress. Trump’s January 2025 inauguration fueled the push, with Eduardo Bolsonaro’s US visits intensifying.
February 2025 saw Rumble’s return and, on the 26th, the Judiciary Committee’s approval after hours of contentious debate, locking in the bill’s trajectory.
Immediate Aftermath of the Vote
The State Department doubled down post-vote, while Eduardo Bolsonaro and allies took to social media, framing the decision as a win against STF overreach.
Brazil’s government remains publicly silent, contrasting with the vocal enthusiasm from Bolsonaro’s camp, who see leverage in the US move.
Broader Implications for Bilateral Ties
The bill could strain Brazil-US trade and migration ties, echoing 2017 disputes over deportation policies that tested diplomatic patience.
Moraes’ targeting rekindles digital sovereignty debates, pitting Brazil’s legal framework against US priorities for its tech giants.
Congressional Dynamics at Play
Jim Jordan’s leadership in the Judiciary Committee drove the vote, with Republicans decrying Moraes’ “censorship.” Democrats, outvoted, raised concerns over sanctioning a foreign judge.
The bill’s fate now rests on full House and Senate votes, with Republicans banking on their House edge to push it through in coming months.
Amplifying the Free Speech Debate
The 2024 X suspension stemmed from Moraes’ push to enforce Brazilian law, clashing with US views on unfettered online expression, a rift widened by Trump’s return.
Rumble’s reentry, restoring banned voices, underscores the ongoing tug-of-war over digital platform governance between the two nations.






