STF rules against Zambelli: 10-year sentence and loss of mandate

The First Chamber of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) reached a unanimous decision in a case that marks a significant chapter in Brazilian politics. Federal Deputy Carla Zambelli (PL-SP) and hacker Walter Delgatti were convicted for crimes related to the invasion of the National Council of Justice (CNJ) systems, exposing attempts to destabilize judicial institutions. The trial, concluded on May 14, 2025, brought severe consequences, including prison sentences and million-dollar fines. The ruling reinforces the protection of the Judiciary against cyberattacks and coordinated actions threatening democracy.
The seriousness of the crimes, according to the justices, lies in the intent to undermine public trust in the Justice system. Zambelli, identified as the mastermind behind the scheme, faces the loss of her parliamentary mandate, while Delgatti, the technical executor, is already in preventive detention. The case, involving the creation of false documents, such as a fake arrest warrant against an STF justice, sparked debates about digital security and political responsibility. Below are key points from the trial:
- Zambelli sentenced to 10 years in prison in a closed regime.
- Delgatti received 8 years and 3 months, also in a closed regime.
- A R$2 million fine for moral and collective damages.
- Loss of mandate and ineligibility for Zambelli, pending a Chamber of Deputies decision.
Case origin
In February 2025, the Attorney General’s Office (PGR) filed charges against Carla Zambelli and Walter Delgatti, accusing them of orchestrating a cyberattack on the CNJ. The investigation revealed that Delgatti, known for his expertise in digital invasions, accessed the council’s system using illegally obtained credentials. According to the PGR, the action aimed to insert falsified documents, including a fake arrest warrant against Justice Alexandre de Moraes, to discredit the Judiciary.
Zambelli’s involvement, as a prominent national political figure, shocked parts of the public. The complaint alleged that the deputy not only encouraged Delgatti’s actions but also promised benefits, such as political and financial support, to execute the plan. The PGR emphasized that the acts had political motivations, aiming to incite movements against democratic institutions. The case’s severity was heightened by Zambelli’s role as a parliamentarian, responsible for representing societal interests.
Invasion details
The CNJ system breach occurred on January 4, 2023, as detailed in the investigations. Delgatti, using advanced hacking techniques, bypassed the council’s security mechanisms. He inserted false documents that, if undetected, could have caused significant confusion in the judicial system. The PGR revealed that the fake warrant against Moraes was designed to circulate on social media, amplifying narratives of distrust in the STF.
The operation was uncovered after monitoring suspicious activities in the CNJ system. Digital security teams identified the alterations and traced the actions to Delgatti, who, in a statement to the Federal Police, confessed to the crime and implicated Zambelli as the main orchestrator. Delgatti’s cooperation with authorities provided critical evidence, including communication records between him and the deputy. These elements were decisive for the PGR’s complaint and the subsequent STF conviction.
Penalty justification
The First Chamber’s decision was unanimous, with votes from Justices Alexandre de Moraes, Luiz Fux, Flávio Dino, Cristiano Zanin, and Cármen Lúcia. Moraes, the case’s rapporteur, classified Zambelli’s actions as a direct affront to the dignity of the Justice system. He highlighted that the deputy played a leadership role in the scheme, instigating Delgatti to commit the crimes. The 10-year closed-regime sentence reflects the severity of the charges and the potential impact of the acts on institutional stability.
For Delgatti, the 8-year-and-3-month sentence considered his cooperation with the investigations, though his technical responsibility in the invasion was confirmed. The justices also imposed a R$2 million fine, to be paid jointly by the convicts, as compensation for the damage caused to the Judiciary’s credibility. The ruling sends a clear message that cyberattacks against public institutions will face severe consequences.
Political repercussions
Zambelli’s conviction sparked intense debates in the political arena. Allied parliamentarians questioned the decision, alleging political motivations. Conversely, leaders from parties opposing Jair Bolsonaro’s government, to which Zambelli is aligned, defended the sentence as a milestone in protecting democratic institutions. The loss of her mandate, if confirmed by the Chamber of Deputies, represents a significant setback for the Liberal Party (PL), which loses one of its most prominent figures.
Zambelli’s ineligibility, as stipulated by the Clean Record Law, also reshapes the electoral landscape. The deputy, who had secured significant votes in previous elections, will be barred from running for public office until the sentence is served or overturned in higher courts. The case reignites discussions about the role of parliamentarians in promoting narratives that challenge institutional legitimacy.
Timeline of events
The Zambelli-Delgatti case followed a complex trajectory, marked by detailed investigations and judicial twists. Below are the main milestones:
- January 2023: Delgatti invades the CNJ system and inserts false documents.
- February 2023: The PGR begins investigations following reports of suspicious activities.
- August 2023: Delgatti confesses to the Federal Police and implicates Zambelli.
- February 2025: The PGR formalizes charges against both.
- May 2025: The STF concludes the trial with a unanimous conviction.
Digital security in focus
The CNJ breach exposed vulnerabilities in Brazil’s judicial systems, raising concerns about the protection of sensitive data. Cybersecurity experts noted that the case underscores the need for investments in defense technologies against hacker attacks. The CNJ, post-incident, implemented new security measures, including multi-factor authentication and continuous system activity monitoring.
The case also highlighted the role of political actors in cyberattacks. A parliamentarian’s involvement in such a scheme raised alarms about the instrumentalization of digital crimes for ideological purposes. Judicial authorities emphasized the importance of holding both executors and masterminds accountable for actions threatening democratic order.
Societal reactions
The STF’s decision was widely discussed on social media and in the press. Groups supporting Zambelli organized protests in some cities, defending the deputy and criticizing the Judiciary. In contrast, civil society organizations, such as the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB), praised the ruling, highlighting its role in defending the rule of law.
Opinion polls conducted by independent institutes showed that public trust in the STF remains divided. While some approve of the court’s handling of high-profile cases, others question the impartiality of its decisions. The Zambelli case, due to its visibility, intensified these debates, with repercussions in public discourse about the Judiciary’s role.
Future judicial steps
The STF trial does not conclude the case. Zambelli and Delgatti can still appeal the decision, potentially prolonging the process in higher courts. The deputy’s defense has already indicated plans to file appeals, arguing that the evidence against her is insufficient. The review of these appeals could take months, keeping the case in the political and judicial spotlight.
Meanwhile, the Chamber of Deputies will await the final judgment—when no further appeals are possible—to deliberate on Zambelli’s mandate loss. The process in the House is expected to be another point of tension, with potential to mobilize the deputy’s allies and opponents.
CNJ’s role in the crisis
The National Council of Justice, the target of the attack, played a central role in responding to the incident. After the breach, the body intensified efforts to secure its systems and collaborated with the Federal Police in the investigation. The swift identification of system alterations was crucial in preventing greater harm, such as the widespread circulation of false documents.
The CNJ also took the lead in initiatives to train Judiciary staff in cybersecurity. Training programs and partnerships with technology companies were implemented to strengthen the council’s digital infrastructure. The case served as a warning to other public institutions, which are now reviewing their security protocols.
PL party developments
Zambelli’s conviction poses a challenge for the Liberal Party, which faces the loss of one of its most charismatic leaders. The PL, a key opposition force, must address the political fallout of the decision. Party leaders have begun discussing strategies to mitigate the sentence’s effects, including nominating new figures to fill the void left by Zambelli.
The deputy’s potential exit could also influence the party’s internal dynamics. Figures aligned with Zambelli may lose influence, while other leaders seek to consolidate their positions. The case, therefore, extends beyond the judicial realm, reshaping political alliances and strategies.
Cybersecurity lessons
The Zambelli-Delgatti case highlighted the growing threat of cybercrimes in Brazil. Experts warn that the use of hackers by political actors is a concerning trend, requiring robust responses from public authorities. Below are measures suggested by experts to prevent future incidents:
- Increased investment in encryption technologies.
- Continuous training for public servants in digital security.
- Creation of specialized teams for cyber incident response.
- Strengthened partnerships with the private sector for threat monitoring.
- Periodic reviews of vulnerabilities in government systems.






