Pular para o conteúdo
Menu
Mix Vale

Minister Fux declares STF’s absolute incompetence and defends total nullity of the case against Bolsonaro and allies

Luís Henrique Costa
Por 11 min de leitura
Compartilhe
Fux Votação
Foto: Fux Votação - Foto: X

Minister Luiz Fux, a member of the Supreme Federal Court’s First Chamber, presented this Wednesday, September 10, 2025, in Brasília, his dissenting vote in the trial of the criminal case against former President Jair Bolsonaro and seven former members of his government, accused of participating in an alleged coup attempt after the 2022 elections. The magistrate argued for the Court’s absolute incompetence to process the case, stating that the defendants lack privileged forum status, rendering all decisions taken so far, including the acceptance of the complaint and the investigations conducted, null and void. This stance contrasts with the previous votes of Alexandre de Moraes, the rapporteur, and Flávio Dino, who rejected the preliminary objections and proceeded to the merits, proposing convictions for crimes such as the violent abolition of the Democratic Rule of Law and armed criminal organization. The trial, which began last week, is taking place amid debates over the validity of plea bargains and the volume of evidence presented by the Attorney General’s Office, with defenses alleging a violation of the right to defense due to the large amount of data. The session, broadcast live on the STF’s website, reflects internal tensions in the Chamber, where Fux emphasized the need to assess competence before proceeding with any judgment of guilt, highlighting that the Supreme Court must prioritize safeguarding the Constitution without overstepping jurisdictional limits.

Publicidade

Fux’s statement immediately drew attention among legal observers and supporters of the defendants, who see the vote as an opportunity for appeals that could take the case to the Court’s plenary or even to the first instance of the Federal Justice.

  • The defendants include generals such as Paulo Sérgio Nogueira and Augusto Heleno, as well as figures like Alexandre Ramagem and Anderson Torres, all former public officeholders who left their positions before the formal complaint.
  • Bolsonaro’s defense argued that the former president, currently without an elected position, does not qualify for privileged forum, and the large volume of evidence, estimated at thousands of pages, compromised the adversarial process.
  • Fux cited historical precedents, such as changes in the interpretation of privileged forum since 2018, to reinforce that the trivialization of this institute undermines procedural fairness.

This preliminary objection of incompetence, if supported by another minister, could suspend the trial and reopen discussions about the appropriate venue for the case.

Publicidade

Procedural preliminary objections raised by the defenses

The defenses of the accused presented several preliminary objections during their oral arguments last week, focusing on flaws that, according to them, invalidate the proceedings from the outset. Fux, in his initial vote on these issues, partially aligned with these arguments, particularly regarding the absence of privileged forum for the defendants. He argued that none of the involved parties hold positions with privileged forum at the time of the complaint, which would shift competence to lower courts, such as the common Federal Justice. This view, expressed with emphasis on constitutional principles, contrasts with Moraes’ position, who defended the continuation in the STF based on connections to acts committed during the exercise of public functions.

The minister emphasized that the Supreme Court, as the guardian of the Constitution, must verify its own competence before analyzing the merits, avoiding what he called an “improper downgrade” to a smaller chamber. This critique of the First Chamber’s structure, composed of five ministers, suggests that the plenary, with 11 members, would be the appropriate venue for a case of such gravity, ensuring greater debate and plurality of voices.

In a more extensive paragraph, Fux explored the jurisprudential evolution of privileged forum, recalling that recent constitutional amendments limited the institute to crimes committed during and related to the office, not to subsequent events. For him, the defendants lost any privileged status at the end of Bolsonaro’s term in January 2023, rendering the STF incompetent since the complaint was received in March of this year. This analysis, which lasted about 40 minutes in reading, included references to philosophers like Seneca to illustrate the importance of the adversarial process since antiquity, reinforcing that the judge must act with detachment and humility to acquit in case of doubt.

  • The preliminary objection of violation of the right to defense was another point addressed, with allegations of a “data tsunami” without adequate time for analysis by the defenses.
  • Questions about the plea bargain of Mauro Cid, one of the cooperating defendants, were rejected by Moraes, but Fux indicated caution regarding omissions in the statements.
  • Requests for recusal of the rapporteur were unanimously denied in the initial phase, but Fux reiterated the duty of impartiality throughout the process.

These preliminary discussions occupied much of today’s session, postponing the full vote on the merits to subsequent statements.

Fux’s arguments on impartiality and adversarial process

Fux dedicated a significant portion of his vote to guaranteeing the adversarial process and the right to a full defense, fundamental principles of Brazilian criminal procedure. He criticized what he saw as haste in the proceedings, especially given the volume of evidence collected by the Federal Police, which includes messages, audios, and documents from allegedly coup-related meetings. For the minister, the judge cannot confuse their role with that of an investigator or prosecutor, needing to maintain detachment to ensure the fullness of the right to defense.

Publicidade

In a more narrative section, Fux described the STF’s role not as an executor of political judgments but as a strict interpreter of legality, rejecting conveniences that silence dissenting voices in the Court. He pointed out that relegating the case to the First Chamber, instead of the plenary, could exclude perspectives that “sanitize” alternative views on the facts, compromising the robustness of the final decision. This observation, delivered with a firm tone, echoed Fux’s previous criticisms of precautionary measures imposed on Bolsonaro, such as an ankle monitor, which he considered disproportionate in past judgments.

The analysis continued with an emphasis on the judiciary’s responsibility to convict only with absolute certainty, invoking humility to acquit amid doubts. Fux mentioned that the current understanding of privileged forum is “very recent,” dating from 2025, and that the defendants, without positions at the time of the complaint, fall outside this interpretive extension. This line of reasoning, supported by references to classical legal works, aims to reinforce the process’s credibility, avoiding accusations of judicial activism.

Subsequent paragraphs explored the duty of impartiality, with Fux warning that the STF must avoid decisions that seem convenient, focusing on the legal or illegal. He implicitly criticized the trivialization of privileged forum, which has undergone multiple changes over the years, leading to inconsistent interpretations.

  • The adversarial process must be full, allowing detailed analysis of all evidence without haste.
  • The right to a full defense incorporates historical lessons, such as Seneca’s, about balanced decisions.
  • Procedural doubts, such as competence, precede the merits to avoid future nullities.

This section of the vote, lasting about 20 minutes, highlighted Fux’s technical depth, known for his expertise in procedural law.

Context of the plot investigated by the PGR

The criminal case under trial refers to the so-called “crucial core” of the alleged criminal organization that, according to the Attorney General’s Office, orchestrated plans to subvert the 2022 election results, when Bolsonaro lost to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. The investigations, initiated in 2023 by the Federal Police, revealed meetings discussing a decree of state of defense to annul the ballots, as well as monitoring of authorities such as the case’s rapporteur. The defendants deny any coup intent, attributing the conversations to legitimate discussions about institutional security.

Fux, addressing this preliminary objection, did not delve into the merits but reinforced that without clear competence, examining evidence would be premature. He described the process as one that aims to ensure each defendant the fullness of the adversarial process, criticizing what he saw as undue acceleration. In medium-length paragraphs, the minister listed elements that, for him, configure incompetence, such as the loss of positions by the accused before the formal complaint in February 2025.

The PGR, in final arguments spanning 517 pages, classified Bolsonaro as the organization’s leader, requesting cumulative penalties that could exceed 40 years in prison. However, Fux emphasized that the STF is competent to originally process only authorities with privileged forum, not former officeholders without direct connection to the current position.

  • Evidence includes plea bargains from military and civilian figures, but Fux questioned their validity without prior competence analysis.
  • Meetings in 2022 allegedly discussed military intervention, but defenses claim the absence of concrete acts.
  • The case connects to the January 8, 2023, events, with vandalism in public buildings, but Fux prioritized procedural flaws.

These points were explored in cohesive blocks, blending facts and legal principles to support the nullity.

Initial repercussions in the trial

Fux’s vote provoked immediate reactions in the session, with defense lawyers expressing optimism about possible appeals. He continued analyzing other preliminary objections, such as the violation of the right to defense, partially accepting the claim of insufficient time to examine the vast evidentiary material. For the minister, the “data tsunami” mentioned by the defenses compromises procedural balance, leading to the nullity of subsequent acts.

In a longer passage, Fux debated the distinction between constitutional interpretation and political judgment, stating that the STF must avoid decisions that appear convenient, focusing on the legal or illegal. This indirect critique of the case’s handling by the Chamber generated tension, especially after interruptions in the previous session, when Fux complained about interjections during Moraes’ vote.

The expectation now falls on the votes of Cármen Lúcia and Cristiano Zanin, who may form a majority against Fux’s divergences. If isolated, his stance will serve as a basis for motions and appeals to the plenary, potentially prolonging the outcome.

  • Bolsonaro’s lawyers saw in the vote an opportunity to challenge the final judgment.
  • Legal observers noted Fux’s alignment with procedural garantism in sensitive cases.
  • The session was paused for internal debates, reflecting the impact of the statements.

Details of the accusations and defenses presented

The accusations against the group involve serious crimes, such as attempting a coup d’état, provided for in the National Security Law, and participation in an armed criminal organization, with minimum penalties of 4 years each. The PGR relied on statements from collaborators, such as Lieutenant Colonel Mauro Cid, who detailed plans to decree a state of siege and arrest opponents. Fux, however, expressed reservations about the plea bargain, citing multiple versions and possible coercions.

The defenses, in oral arguments lasting up to two hours each, denied any concrete plan, claiming that discussions were hypothetical and do not constitute crimes. For Fux, without resolving the preliminary objections, proceeding would be a serious error, potentially fueling international appeals or within the Court itself.

In the final paragraphs of his initial statement, the minister invoked the duty of judicial humility, recalling that convicting requires certainty, and acquitting, courage amid doubts. This philosophy, applied to the case, suggests he may diverge on the merits, proposing partial acquittals or reduced penalties for defendants with lesser involvement, such as Ramagem, whose parliamentary immunity suspended part of the accusations.

  • Imputed crimes include qualified damage to the Three Powers’ buildings on January 8.
  • Defenses requested the nullity of Cid’s plea bargain due to omissions and contradictions in eight statements.
  • Fux emphasized that the STF does not judge political conveniences, but strict legalities.

The session continues with complementary analyses, maintaining the focus on procedural guarantees.

Publicidade
Assuntos

Luís Henrique Costa é jornalista formado pela FMU, editor-chefe e fundador do Mix Vale, portal de notícias em atividade desde 2011. Responde pela direção editorial do veículo, que cobre Brasil e mundo em economia, benefícios sociais, esportes, tecnologia, ciência e entretenimento. Atua na área há mais de 15 anos e lidera uma equipe de cerca de 15 colaboradores.

Notícias relacionadas

Mais lidas

  1. Ciência

    Meteoro no Nordeste: bólido cruza o céu de cinco estados às 21h34 e mobiliza buscas por fragmentos na Paraíba

  2. Caixa Econômica Federal

    Pé-de-Meia paga parcela de R$ 1.000,00 a aprovados no ensino médio de 2026 entre fevereiro e março de 2027

  3. Política

    Com obstrução parcial no intestino, Jair Bolsonaro é internado no hospital DF Star em Brasília

  4. INSS

    Recuperação da senha Gov.br pelo celular exige reconhecimento facial ou código por SMS para o Meu INSS

  5. EUA

    Terremoto em Los Angeles atinge magnitude 4,2 e causa tremores leves em Commerce na madrugada

  6. Matéria Publicitária

    MineMV é o novo jogo grátis de construir com blocos; veja como jogar e liberado para todas as idades

  7. Política

    Regulamentação da escala 5×2 pelo governo encarece cálculo da hora extra a partir de 16 de dezembro

  8. Santa Catarina

    Acidente de trânsito na SC-108 envolve carro e moto e deixa motociclista morto em São Ludgero

  9. Mundo

    Jornalista italiano Corrado Augias morre aos 91 anos; presidente da Itália lamenta a perda

  10. Loterias

    Rendimento de R$ 40 milhões da Mega-Sena 3088 chega a R$ 337 mil por mês no Tesouro Direto